I enjoy the way the website is laid out but, it is pretty average. I don't like the way some people flag reviews.
I've been at this website since 2007, and I've only encountered ONE Scammer. But the Staff was quick to remove him. All and all the site is very safe, very helpful, and VERY fun.
MyAnimeList has a rating of 3.1 stars from 23 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. MyAnimeList ranks 8th among Anime sites.