• Bookmark

    Elfster

Elfster

Write a Review

Overview

Elfster has a rating of 2.8 stars from 125 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Elfster ranks 2nd among Christmas sites.

  • Shipping
    4
  • Returns
    4
  • Quality
    10
Positive reviews (last 12 months): 11.1%
Positive
1
Neutral
0
Negative
8
View ratings trends
1
See all photos
How would you rate Elfster?
Top Positive Review

“Excellent customer service”

George T.
12/1/18

I have a few computer challenged friends in my gift exchange. Elfster's online chat answers every question immediately for them. The site is fantastic so easy to navigate and makes getting worthless, thoughtless gifts a thing of the past.

See positive reviews
Top Critical Review

“Terrible - doesn't work”

S M.
12/4/23

Only 1/2 of the people receiving the invitation could join. It says 9 accepted but that's 9 invited. Many of us could not accept or go beyond this screen. So much trying and trying to make it work. A complete waste of time. And thanks for all the spam that you get once you make an account. I can see the invite but can't join or see who's joined. Below it says I'm not participating. All the clicks and trying never got it to work. And the admin had no luck either.

See critical reviews

Reviews (125)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (43) gift exchange (30)
Thumbnail of user lindseyk34
Massachusetts
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
November 19th, 2018

Great idea for the holidays especially for those who live far from one another. There is even an option to make a wish list and you can secretly follow people as well. I even see what left from a holiday wish list to buy birthday presents some time. I was also able to add wish lists for my children and everyone can still see them even though they don't participate in the exchange. Their customer service "helper elf" is awesome too. They walked me through changing someone's email. Lovely website and experience using elfster!

Thumbnail of user cayceb1
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 25th, 2018

I'm starting to do gift exchanges both on an international level and a personal family level. This. Is. Perfect. It offers anonymity as well as conversation and just more than I thought of. So amazing.

Thumbnail of user macp11
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 1st, 2018

I organized a gift exchange for 150 people. There were a few kinks with the website. Some people didn't receive notifications of secret messages and quite a few times I got "bad gateway" loads. However, with this issues all the customer service elves have been extremely helpful. I wish it was a bit more user friendly, though. Many of my people had issues figuring out how to use the wish list and find their recipient. I also wish it had a questionnaire feature. This was a major issue for my exchange. We had 24 questions I needed post within Elfster and it was very hard to enter them into the system.

Thumbnail of user suzen
Canada
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 30th, 2018

My family lives in multiple provinces. I was able to invite them all by facebook and email where they could sign up if they wanted to join in. You set the draw date and the site doe the rest! You can even post items on a wish list for the person who picked your name (including sites like amazon). I was even able to add people after the draw date. Their live customer service helped me two days in a row promptly and were very courteous.

Thumbnail of user gaylem102
New Hampshire
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 29th, 2019

The Elfster app is amazing and my family LOVED using it! It's super easy, you can check in anonymously with participants, and I even got alerts when wish list items went on sale! Everyone was VERY happy with their gifts. Highly recommended 5

Thumbnail of user kimw337
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 19th, 2018

I was having issues with my account this evening. The person on the online chat help was terrific. They stayed with me through the whole process and got me all fixed up. Best service I've had in a long time. Thanks Elfster!

Thumbnail of user jenniferc758
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 17th, 2018

I love when you send a Chat for help, they are always in character. Always willing to elf you! A few small issues, wish it would remember my email list, and had to merge accounts from two years, but they're quick to resolve, and it's fun!

Thumbnail of user marys3994
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 1st, 2021

Short stop was patient and courteous and hung in there with me until we reached resolution... i wish more reps were like him... he needs to be cloned... it did take a while but the situation was complex... he asked the right questions to get to s solution. I hive him 10 stars

Thumbnail of user barbaras588
Maryland
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 22nd, 2018

I went on to set up our annual (25 years) gift exchange to find the site had been changed/absorbed by Elfster. My history was not there, many of my participants were missing? I was near tears. OK, I cried. I clicked on the elf and explained what had happened and Tricia and the head Elf were able to restore most of my information so the name exchange could go on tomorrow, Thanksgiving, as it has for 25 years. Thank you so much Elfster. This is what the season is about, helping others, family and traditions.

Thumbnail of user secrets5
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 19th, 2018

This is an amazing website to help you get your secret santa organized and just wonderful! I am so pleased with customer service that has amazing and very sweet helpers. I would totally recommend this!

Thumbnail of user justineq
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 16th, 2018

Not only does Elfster draw the names for you, but you are easily able to un-assign an individual, and reassign someone else to them (if need be)! I've used this with my friends and student classes. They loved it! Elizabeth, the Buckeye Elf was such a huge help in answering my questions. An excellent experience overall!

Thumbnail of user trinab99
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 15th, 2021

Sprinkles the elf assisted me today and was able to correct my issue in a matter of seconds. They kept me laughing and even sent some jokes to continue my amusement. Hands down the best online customer service I have ever encountered. Keep it up Elfster!

Service
Thumbnail of user davids7259
Connecticut
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 29th, 2021

We will be using Elfster again - it's incredibly easy and replaced hours of mental wrangling - usually done after we've all had our wine - with a complete and accurate exchange! As our family grows the politics of these things require finessing - Elfster took the guesswork out of the process! ALSO - their customer service is lightning fast and pleasant to work with!

Products used:
ELFSTER ON LINE

Service
Value
Quality
Thumbnail of user kathryno23
Oregon
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 9th, 2018

Love Elfster. Have utilized for our wives club secret Santa ornament exchanges and secret pen pal gifts. Have even utilized for exchanges for both my kids! I am a busy working mom, and appreciate that all the info can easily be accessed or added to/from the app.

Thumbnail of user sonjac22
Pennsylvania
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 1st, 2018

Jewel was a GEM! Gave me the info I needed quickly and helped me with other set-up issues also- which was a huge help because I am new to Elfster this Holiday Season! I did not feel rushed with my questions and they were answered completely! Thank you Jewel!

Thumbnail of user barbarac442
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 25th, 2018

We have been using Elfster for years and it never fails us! I was having trouble with a couple of our accounts and Elizabeth the Buckeye Elf was wonderfully helpful! Super friendly and knowledgeable elves. Elfster keeps our information for past years and we are able to delete or update. I like that it allows the buyer to mark item purchased to let others know that it is no longer needed to avoid receiving multiples. We use it for birthdays, too. List can be updated at any time. Elfster is the best!

Thumbnail of user adeg
Mexico
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
November 25th, 2018

Elfster has saved time for us every year we use it since 2014. It is so flexible and allows you last minute changes. The tool is very well thought, intuitive and the resources for making your wishlist makes life easier and avoid trouble by the anonymous questions when doubtful.

The elf service I requested was efficient and precise.

Thank you!

Thumbnail of user emilyn67
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 30th, 2018

I'll just tell ya, these people are true elves with true elf magic. Today Elizabeth not only helped me with my organizer questions, she provided pure, joyous, holiday spirit. You're a real one, Elizabeth the Buckeye elf.

Thumbnail of user elsap125
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 10th, 2021

I really botched up my Elfster account and Elf Holly was fantastic. She took care of all my issues with great patience & professionalism and a great sense of humor. So happy with excellent customer service.

Service
Thumbnail of user edwinf21
California
1 review
4 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 12th, 2018

Had issues consolidating my children's account's for a gift exchange. Was going to just leave it as it was and just deal with it. Then i saw the "Need Help? Chat Live" come up. And i was thinking, "Who would be working on a Sunday?'' And it was Shelly the Sweet Elf! She fixed everything! You are a blessing Shelly! I'm going to personally tell Santa that you deserve a gift!

Thumbnail of user shalamarh1
California
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 10th, 2018

Tricia the Christmas Card Elf was amazing. I needed the roles changed and was unable to find out how since they just updated the website today. She said she'll take care of it and send me an email once it is completed. Once I receive the email that the task has been completed I will update my review to 5 stars. We have been using this site since 2009. This year will be our 10th Christmas Exchange.

Thumbnail of user laurenr132
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 1st, 2018

My mother was having a really hard time trying to recover her password and I was able to get online and speak with Meghan the representative. She was so helpful and so nice. She literally helped me within a minute. We have been using Elfster to do our secret santa for 3 year now and we will always use them!

Thumbnail of user josiahs18
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 26th, 2018

Been using elfster to organize multiple secret santa gift exchanges every year. Elfster has always been on point and has made it very easy to manage these exchanges. Especially for the older folks in my family.

Would recommend to everyone and anyone who wants to do this fun secret santa gift exchange game!

Thumbnail of user audrat9
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 11th, 2020

One of my participants put in a wrong email address and I couldn't find them. Needless to say I was frustrated and couldn't figure out why I couldn't see them. The customer service person for Elfster looked up the information, didn't get frustrated with me with all my questions and merged the two accounts together. I'm back in business and ready to draw names for the gift exchange. Will right another review when we complete our gift exchange.

Thumbnail of user dianad927
New Jersey
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 21st, 2021

Noel from Elfster was able to get back to me super fast! For some reason, the creator of the gifts exchange event made me a child account under my main account. Noel was able to merge the accounts and now we are back on track! Thanks so much for all you do!

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Free secret santa generator. Easy to use gift exchange app to organize office parties, family or friends events online.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user charlesc197
Charles C.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Elfster?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Elfster?