Moon Magic has a rating of 3.8 stars from 511 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Moon Magic most frequently mention customer service, wrong size, and beautiful jewelry. Moon Magic ranks 9th among Custom Jewelry sites.
Seriously obsessed! My first ring from Moon Magic was Moonstone Flourish, and I just recently tried their new floating design, the invisible band gives it this cool, magical vibe. Beautiful craftsmanship and the energy of these stones is simply amazing!
Purchased a lovely ring - "rose gold" rubbed away within 3 months of normal wear. When I messaged about this, they said it was normal wear and tear and outside of their return window so nothing to be done. Very disappointed and will never shop these products again. I would expect $20 for these rings, not $120.
Jewelry not like the pictures on their website. Terrible quality. I've been scammed. Do not buy from this company!
Hello Villa,
We appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review. We are sorry that you are not satisfied with your experience. Unfortunately, there is no order number for us to check all the details, please feel free to reconnect with our Customer Support Team so that we can investigate it further.
Kind Regards,
Moon Magic
Excellent company, beautiful products, and great customer service. The products are great quality and beautiful. Will continue to use this company in the future and refer them to friends!
Products used:
Rings
Hello Nicole,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I was so excited to get my jewelry that my fiancé got me for my birthday. Within two weeks, the rose gold was rubbed off. For the price point, I would have expected maybe a bit more time before that.
Hello Michelle,
We are very sorry to hear about your experience and that you received a defective ring. If you contact our support you will be able to receive a free replacement or full refund. We are very sorry for any inconvenience.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Moon Magic were amazing in fixing my order that was a little too big (not their fault). The jewelry is beautiful, great quality. I will definitely be buying more.
Hello Dina,
Many thanks for your positive feedback - it really means a lot to us!
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Had to return the ring 3 times (first time was my fault, wrong size) and each time we exhanged, it was extremely easy and hassle free. The jewelry is amazing and I would highly recommend it!
Hello Josh,
Thank you so much for this great 5-star review. We really appreciate you being a loyal customer and helping to share the word about us. We’re here for you anytime.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Would just like to say that I cannot recommend this company enough. I purchased an item on Friday 12th of March and it arrived in the UK to my home address on Monday 15th March although I had an issue when the item had arrived I emailed the company and within less than 24 hours it was all resolved and Inna has been absolutely amazing very caring and fantastic customer service, this has inspired me even more to use Moon Magic for the rest of my purchases, I cannot thank you enough for your kindness shown and compassion in a world that is currently dis regulated.
Hello Hannah,
Thank you for your wonderful comment and positive feedback, you just made our day!
Kind Regards,
Moon Magic
I have ordered from this company two or three times now. Some items I've received have been pretty and just like (if not better) than the photo. However, some items I've received are not even slightly like the photo and the stone is way smaller than advertised. I ordered the raw moonstone ring in silver and really liked it (the shape wasn't as pretty as on the site/instagram but I was all right with that). The blue shift was really cool at different angles and lighting. I then ordered the same ring in rose gold and the one that came was not at all the same quality. The stone size was half the size of my silver one and the blue shift/vibrancy was nonexistent. Because they offer a petite version of the ring for much cheaper, I was frustrated I didn't receive the same size and qualify that I did before. The response of stones are unique and will all look different doesn't satisfy my frustration because they have control over the size of the stone (especially since they now offer multiple sizes for different prices).
Hello Ashley,
Many thanks for your feedback. We are very sad that you are not happy with the size of the raw crystal ring you received. However, if you are not satisfied with the ring you can return it for an exchange or for a full refund. The Petite Raw version is different from the regular Raw Crystal ring as you know and no two rings look the same thanks to its natural gemstone beauty and unusual, untreated shape. We hope you understand.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
So I never leave reviews like this but this is ridiculous. I was very excited to order from this website but customer service makes the process very bad. So my boyfriend got me the same ring for our anniversary, I had ordered the same one in silver not knowing. So we wanted to do an exchange for his and an exchange for another item for mine. We were given the instructions for shipping the items back. When asked how much the shipping back is to them and multiple emails I have not received a response. I think it's ridiculous that the item we ordered didn't require a shipping fee and we wanted an exchange for each of the items. However, since we have not gotten a response I just decided I'm going to be returning both items. It's very sad because I was super excited to order from here but honestly the process of an exchange or return is stressful. If they are able to give a 15% refund if you keep the item why wouldn't they be able to cover the shipping for exchanges. Sorry but I will not be ordering from here ever again and will not be recommending the website to any of my friends. Alsooo the customer service rep kept confusing my name with a different name and called my boyfriend my name but spelt wrong? It's very insensitive to think the person who is helping you is not even really reading the emails.
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Paula,
Thank you for your feedback. We are truly sorry to hear that you are not happy with our service. Please, be rest assured that we are working around a clock to always find the best possible resolution and we appreciate your kind understanding that we must proceed according to our company policies.
We are glad to see that refunds for your both order were made on September 28th.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
My husband got me one Rainbow Moonstone ring and two Labradorite ring. The gemstones are authentic and the customer service is the best.
Thank you MoonMagic!
Hello Roxana,
Thank you for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you love your beautiful Moon Magic jewelry! <3
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I am not one to ever write a bad review but can't help it because of the poor customer experience I have ever recieved. It is one thing to sell people faulty rings, which clearly is the case if multiple people have complained about the same thing, but what is WORSE is not taking responsibility as a business and RECTIFYING it with your customers. My partner bought me a moonstone ring for my birthday and I was so excited because it was a lovely ring. I wore it on my birthday night (first time) and my partner noticed the stone on the dining table. I then contacted the company and initially they were really good and said they can ether replace it or give me an item of a similar value. Although I loved the style of ring I received, I was scared that it may happen again because of the design. So I picked the only other ring I liked which was of a similar value (difference was about $17) and then I sent that in. Didn't hear back for a few weeks so I assumed all good, then I contacted them again to see if the new ring had been sent. The different lady Marlene said I had to pay the difference of $17, which I then said was not what I was told originally. She then offered to split the difference of $8 and then it just got me so mad, like just pay the difference for all the messing around I have had to go through because YOUR product is faulty. So I have given up and paid the difference of $8, a month later I still have no ring, and am out of pocket scared the next one will probably break again and writing a bad review. How not to run a business 101.
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Taylor,
We are truly sorry to hear that your experience with Moon Magic was not as magical as you have hoped for but happy to see that our customer service did request a new ring only three days after you have agreed to pay the split price difference and that your new Moonstone Ring - Loveliness was delivered on December 2nd. We sincerely hope that you like it!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Sorry for my first review, It took along time to deliver but in the end, I received it and I am so happy with the bracelet that i ordered
Thank you again
Hello Maiada, Thank you so much for the 5 stars. We are very happy that you had a great experience ordering with us! Kind Regards, Moon Magic
Perfect example of great boast little roast. I fell for their 7-14 days international delivery scam and ended up ordering one.it was supposed to be for a function. Its been 1 month, my parcel hasnt arrived. The courier service is telling to contact the seller. But moonmagic is saying they can't do anything about it nor will they cancel it and i should just sit and wait. I can only imagine what will happen if the product somehow arrives and is faulty or smthn, which is very likely after I've seen so many bad reviews on other sites. Their helpline is only effective when you haven't placed any order. The second you make payment, you're no more a priority. They'll send you those good for nothing copy paste replies after days. But the second you comment anything publicly They'll delete your comment. Also enough with using covid as an excuse. It's been more than a year, why don't they incorporate this delay when giving us that estimated delivery time. Its because then the customer wont be lured in.
So I've received the parcel after like 35 days. The product is okayish. It's definitely not worth 200$. It'd be acceptable if the price range was around 100 usd.
Products used:
I bought a stacked ring
Hello Kalim,
Thank you for your constructive feedback and for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We are working hard to keep up with deliveries and customer service requests in these uncertain times. We’re sorry if we’ve fallen short of your expectations, and are dedicated to finding a solution for every individual experience. Please feel free to reach out to our customer service team for additional information on the status of your order. Currently, we have reduced staff due to safety protocols and apologize for any delays you may experience.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I ordered a beautiful ring which looks like junk jewelry after 10 months. The basic material ist shining black trough the rose gold plating.
Products used:
ring
Hello Jessica,
Thank you for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We appreciate your honesty and are taking all customer feedback (both positive and negative) seriously. While we do clearly state our 30-day warranty policy on our website, we work with each customer individually to find a solution to their issue if that time frame has passed. We stand behind our products and are dedicated to finding an equitable outcome for each shopper on a case-by-case basis.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Above the clouds turned black in under two days. My finger turned green and was swollen. The opal looks pretty but I'm not sure if its real. I got a moonstone ring, queenly (a month-ish ago), from them too and hated it out of the box. It was definitely pastic looking and got caught on my pocket because the setting was high for my preference. I asked for a refund and they took two days to suggest I exchange and not return. (I exchanged for the opal ring) though i insisted on a return three times total. They acted like they could not read the word return. Mind you, I paid for 2 day shipping and live in Florida so I was well under the 30 days.
I attached a picture of the opal ring next to another ring I got from them in rose gold as a partner band, that ring is NICE and hasnt tarnished at all and I shower with it. I have one other partner band from them(got it at the same time as my first order) that one still looks pretty, the silver is looking dull but not bad.
They have terrible quality control obviously, they are deceitful about the stones they "hand pick" and costumer service is good unless you want a return without exchange. Over all I'd say a 2ish out of 5 stars for now. I have mixed feelings. They have offered to send me something else (not give my money back) after I e-mailed about the opal turning black in under 2 days. I hope this next item is nice. Last chance to make it up, Moon Magic. Hope you get it right. Third time is a charm. :) get it?
Hello Nikki,
Thank you for sharing your experience. We are very sorry to see what happened.
I just went through the email conversation between you and our colleague and I can't see that you requested a refund at any point. Because of that, our agent didn't mention that option but offered other options. We are issuing a refund without any problems, we also refunded you as per your request 10% as you didn't apply discount code once you were purchasing. We are glad to see that you pick a free replacement again and you will be refunded for the balance shortly.
Also, I am really sorry to hear your ring has caused a green discoloration, I know how frustrating this can be. However, it is, unfortunately, a common complaint caused by the copper present in all sterling silver jewelry. This can be especially common in hot, humid climates as moisture in the air or skin can make the copper react in this way. We recommend using a silver cloth to regularly polish your ring as this will really help.
All the best,
Moon Magic
I created a review from trustpilot and the seller flagged and reported my review.
I updated it but trustpilot still hasn't released the review after I responded to it. Here was the review I made that the company did not want to tell you.
Update: I just received a notification from trustpilot that my review below was flagged REPORTED by the seller! I replied to them that they know their return policy. They know about the foreign transaction fee from their Germany bank. They know about the receipt within 7 days of purchase or you forfeit the right to return it. Most importantly, I have emails to back it up! The fact that the company knows this and has the audacity to report this review says a lot about the kind of seller you are dealing with. Buy at your own risk knowing about this.
--------------------
This is what their website omitted / deliberately did not disclose:
1. You will see a foreign transaction fee in your bank statement / credit card statement because the bank acct they use is from Germany. Although the items are shipped to and from the US.
2. Buyer is responsible for return shipping. So it's not a free return.
3. Even if you have 30 days to return, once you have have the RMA, you only have 7 days to return or you forfeit it.
4. Quality: in my opinion, the gemstones are not as big as in the pictures and cloudy. The ring band is very very very thin.
Buy in your own risk.
Hello Jasmine,
Please accept our apologies for any disappointment your Moon Magic experience may have caused. We work hard to meet and exceed our customers’ expectations, and bring a little bit of magic into their daily lives.
Regarding the transaction fee charged by your credit card institute or the issuer of the card, you used for the purchase. Unfortunately, that is out of our hands. For further information about this, please contact your bank. They will be able to help and explain this fee in more detail. We are very sorry about your experience.
As clearly stated on our website, you will be responsible for the shipping fee on sending the item(s) back to us. However, if you decide to proceed with an exchange, we will cover the shipping costs to send the new item(s) back out to you. Please understand that there needs to be a time frame when you need to return the items, as in the past we have huge delays with that and we need to set the time frame. At any point, if you are not happy with the rings you received you can contact our customer service for an exchange.
All the best,
Moon Magic
I bought the Moonstone Ring - Harlow.
And I'm in love
The ring is all I wished for...
And the service the moon company has given us "over the moon"
I love you guys
Anja from Denmark
Tip for consumers:
The service is perfect
Products used:
Moonstone Ring - Harlow 925 Sterling Silver
Hello Anja,
We are incredibly grateful for the 5-stars! Moon Magic put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Hello Anja,
We are incredibly grateful for the 5-stars! Moon Magic put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I am so amazed by their service. I would highly recommend people to buy jewellery from moon magic...
Hello Umeed,
Thank you for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are very happy that you like our services and unique Moon Magic jewelry!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Only one of the earrings shines. The necklace doesnt shine at all. Only the ring shines a little bit. Not the way I expected to but its definitley not worth the money we paid for.
Hello Maria,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are so sorry to hear that you are not happy with your purchase!
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Amazing customer service!
Marlene C. Thank you for taking the time to send me some different options. You made my day!
Hello Lena,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience, our colleague will definitely be happy to read what you wrote. We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
I would give them zero if I could. Don't be fooled by their edited images. Customer service also sucks pretty bad!
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello,
Please accept our apologies for any disappointment your Moon Magic experience may have caused. We work hard to meet and exceed our customers’ expectations, and bring a little bit of magic into their daily lives. Unfortunately, items worn beyond 30 days are not eligible for return or exchange, as outlined in our warranty.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Still not received my order after 14 days, tracking of the shipment is not working well too... very poor service
Hello,
Thank you very much for your feedback.
I just checked and saw that you are in contact with one of our agents. We will be in touch with you until your package safely reach your home.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Very easy to order. The service was excellent. Jewelry was exactly as expected and it came in a beautiful box.
Hello Marlene,
We are happy that you enjoyed your experience. Thank you very much for your recommendation and your feedback.
All the best,
Moon Magic
Marina is just amazing! One item was out of stock and she helped me so professionally and kindly to find a replacement Can't wait to get my rings!
Hello Jelka,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are very happy that you like our services and we are sure that you'll love MM jewelry too. We are here to help and always make sure that we meet all the customer's requirements.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
It's a gorgeous ring I'm in love with it, I've got a lot of compliments. It shines so bright! Thank you Moon magic team for a good service!
Hello Yulia,
We are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us this note and share your lovely pictures. We're very glad to see that you are in love with your ring.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Since 2016, our mission has been to design jewelry that is as powerful and meaningful as the ones who wear it.
We believe that everyone deserves jewelry that goes beyond the surface. That’s why we handpick each gemstone not just for its beautiful gleam, but for its unique energy and potential for self-expression and healing.
✓ We use 100% authentic, ethically sourced gemstones that are independently tested by GIA (Gemological Institute Of America)
✓ Each piece is designed right here in-house, ensuring nothing but originality in every piece
✓ When it comes to quality, we don't compromise - we use the finest premium metals & have a strict quality control in place
✓ 1.8+ million followers across socials & 500k customers and counting...
✓ Beautiful, gift-ready packaging
Note from our founder - Laura:
Since 2016, Moon Magic has been creating beautiful, high-quality, and affordable jewelry that taps into the powerful energies of gems. Our pieces are not just accessories, but soulful companions designed to resonate with your inner spirit while having a modern style.
Whether you're seeking enhanced intuition, greater self-love, or a confidence boost - our jewelry is created to help you flourish. Consciously handpicked and carefully crafted, each gem offers energizing properties to enrich and beautify your daily life.
We hope the radiant glow of our gems serves you as a reminder of the incredible magic around and especially within you.
Sent with love, from our hands and hearts to yours.
With Love & Magic,
Laura
Hello Kayla,
We are very glad to see that you like your ring. I am really sorry to hear your ring has caused a green discoloration, I know how frustrating this can be. However, it is, unfortunately, a common complaint caused by the copper present in all sterling silver jewelry. This can be especially common in hot, humid climates as moisture in the air or skin can make the copper react in this way. I recommend using a silver cloth to regularly polish your ring as this will really help.
Best regards,
Moon Magic