Moon Magic has a rating of 3.8 stars from 511 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Moon Magic most frequently mention customer service, wrong size, and beautiful jewelry. Moon Magic ranks 9th among Custom Jewelry sites.
Seriously obsessed! My first ring from Moon Magic was Moonstone Flourish, and I just recently tried their new floating design, the invisible band gives it this cool, magical vibe. Beautiful craftsmanship and the energy of these stones is simply amazing!
Purchased a lovely ring - "rose gold" rubbed away within 3 months of normal wear. When I messaged about this, they said it was normal wear and tear and outside of their return window so nothing to be done. Very disappointed and will never shop these products again. I would expect $20 for these rings, not $120.
I paid almost $200 for two items and am still waiting for them. They keep telling me the package was shipped but according to the carrier, only a label was created, no shipment has been made. You can't reach them by phone either - only email, and they have not been helpful. I am frustrated to say the least. If I do receive the items, I will update this post, but until I do, buyer beware!
I ordered 3 different rings.
For some reason, one of the rings that I got was wrong.
I contacted the customer service and they immediately took care of me!
So I want to say a special thanks to Jana who replied super fast to me and also took care on the case!
Also the products are super high-quality and I highly recommend ordering from them!
First thing. The customer service is stellar
Secondly, my order got here really fast. Despite this crazy world we're in right now. And last but definitely not least.
My ring got here, and I instantly fell in love. My moon ring is perfect
Hello Sophia,
We are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us this note and share your lovely pictures. We're very glad to see that you are in love with our Moonstone Ring - La Reina.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Bought a ring and the stone broke less than 3 month later (while driving a car). Apparently the 2 year warranty promised do not cover this. Not sure what is a defect in materials and/or workmanship if this is not.
Hello Agita,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review, it is highly appreciated.
Our warranty is valid against any defects in our materials and/or workmanship. It does not include insurance against physical or accidental wear and/or damage happening outside of our normal returns and exchanges policy.
Our warranty doesn’t cover lost items, scratches that come with normal wear and tear outside of our normal returns and exchanges policy (like a bent ring or broken chain), improper use or storage of your jewelry, improper care of your jewelry including contact with household chemicals, hygiene products like make-up or perfumes, discoloration of stones caused by water, chemicals, sweating, make-up, cooking, prongs wearing out, stones lost by everyday wear, natural inclusions and imperfections of stones and any modification to your jewelry done by a third party outside of Moon Magic Jewelry.
Please feel free to reconnect with our customer support for any questions you might have.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
I had some issues with my first order but the team at Moon Magic went above and beyond to help these issues get sorted and really cared about my needs and preferences. It was really surprising online customer service and they definitely won my heart and brand loyalty with their care.
Hello Liana,
We really appreciate you being a loyal customer and sharing your experience about us. Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this excellent review.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
I had a stone fall out 6 weeks after purchase. I'm very careful with rings that aren't of great quality, but this one is horrible. We all remember Claire's cheap child jewelry… well this isn't far from that. For the price I also expected customer service to help, nope only within 30 days. Not even they think they jewelry will last that long. Search lab created jewels on any reputable jewelers site (helzberg, Jared) and you will find good quality for a low cost.
Hello Dani,
We appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review and we are really sorry that you are not satisfied with your experience.
Upon checking we can see that you have already been in contact with our Customer Support Team and that we have offered the best solution we could. Please feel free to reconnect with our customer support for any questions you might have.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I have purchased 4 different rings from this company since 2020. The last I bought I believe was in 2021. Every single one of those rings (all sterling silver 925) have tarnished. The gems have ALL broken. I rarely even wear these rings and they look about 30 years old now.
Products used:
Rings
Hello Chelsea,
We appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review and we are truly sorry to hear that you have experienced such an issue with your items.
Although rare, Silver and Rose Gold pieces can tarnish over time due to the precious, natural metals present in their composition, such as Copper. Please find more information https://moonmagic.com/blogs/news/tarnished-jewelry.
If your piece does leave a surface mark on your skin, it can easily be washed off with warm water and soap, while any blackening of the piece can be quickly removed with a quality jewelry polishing cloth.
Please reconnect with our customer service for any questions you might have. Hope for your patience and understanding!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I love the jewelry from Moon Magic. It is beautiful, very well priced, creatively different and, each of the stones have history and meaning behind them. The jewelry does not outshine the customer service they offer either - the service they provide shines just as bright. Returns and exchanges made very easily, nice people and beautiful products! A win, win for everyone!
Hello Erika,
We are thrilled to have you as part of the Moon Magic family! Thank you for sharing your kind words with us. It means the world to us and to our entire team! Enjoy your piece of magic.
All the best,
Moon Magic
Not only are the pieces beautiful and unique, the company also contributes back to the world by planting a tree for each purchase. When I emailed to inquire about a product, I got a timely and personal response. Which is so rare to get these days! I can't wait to start my collection and order more!
Hello Alexandra,
Thank you very much for your kind review. We are glad to hear that you are happy with our services. We’re here for you anytime.
All the best,
Moon Magic
I ordered a moonstone ring for my best friend's birthday. She'd been wanting one for forever and was so happy with it.
After not even TWO MONTHS of occasional wear, the stone had completely fallen off. I contacted Moon Magic, but their return policy has a 1 month warrenty.
I paid over 90 bucks to get this ring, and now I'm being offered 'a special discount' on a new one. As if I would want to spend another 45 on a ring that will probably just fall apart again. The quality of the jewerly is poor and not worth the money. Such a shame, since the stone itself was a stunner. Moon Magic, if you had faith in the quality of your product, you would increase the period of warranty. I literally have warrenty on socks that last longer than yours.
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Iianne,
Thanks for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We appreciate your honesty and are taking all customer feedback (both positive and negative) seriously. While we do clearly state our 30-day warranty policy on our website, we work with each customer individually to find a solution to their issue if that time frame has passed. We stand behind our products and are dedicated to finding an equitable outcome for each shopper on a case by case basis.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Looks nothing like the ring on the website, very low quality, cloudy and you can see the glue under the stone. Definitely not worth the money. I was super excited to receive this ring because all the reviews were wonderful and everyone seemed very happy with their purchase not to mention the ring was absolutely stunning. After not liking mine one bit I looked further into reviews and saw they have alot of bad reviews from the BBB and other sites. I will be asking for a exchange but after reading the reviews I dont even know If I want to exchange it or just get my money back which don't seem to happen often based on what ppl have said.
Hello Jessica,
We are very sorry that you don't like the ring. You are more than welcome to return it for an exchange. Please stay in touch with our customer service team and they will do their best to make you happy. When it comes to our Raw rings, no two rings look the same thanks to its natural gemstone beauty and unusual, untreated shape. However, if you are not 100% happy please contact our team and provide them with pictures of the ring.
All the best,
Moon Magic
This company brags about how fabulous their jewelry is but that was not my experience. First thw stone appeared nothing like in the pictures. Second my boyfriend ordered my ring long before he gave it to me. Despite that the fact that I only wore it for 14 days before a stone fell out and that the silver tarnished in 1 day, they would not honor the ring as defective. And they purposely didn't post my one star review to their website. They can't be trusted and they truly only care about the customers happy with their product. Will not make the mistake of purchasing from them again when their is a company that has similar pricing and lifetime warranties.
Hello Casey,
Thank you for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We appreciate your honesty and are taking all customer feedback (both positive and negative) seriously. While we do clearly state our 30-day warranty policy on our website, we work with each customer individually to find a solution to their issue if that time frame has passed. We stand behind our products and are dedicated to finding an equitable outcome for each shopper on a case by case basis.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I found this company, very excited to share with my mother. We chose rings for one another and gifted them to each other for Christmas 2019. I wore my ring a total of 3 times before the band started to look rusted as if it were cheap quality! I thought these rings were good quality and definitely did not expect it to happen so soon- this happened probably 3 months after ordering, I emailed moonmagic about the issue and was basically told it was normal? I don't think something like this should be normal and if so the rings shouldn't be priced so high nor sold as "sterling silver" or real anything! Very disappointed!
Bought two rings for myself for my birthday. Their products marketed as constructed with authentic materialsabsolutely not. I ordered a freshwater pearl ring which was a bead with blue enamel on it and a moonstone ring which looked like cloudy plastic. At a glance the rings are pretty, but you look closer and it looks and feels like the lie that it is.
The sterling silver' bands they claim are stamped with 925 to appear legitimate. 0.925 closely stamped with the jeweler/company trademark is what makes a piece legitimate according to the Federal Trade Commission close but no cigar, Moon Magic. Lets see how my request for a refund is processed.
Hello Steph,
We are very sorry that you are not happy with the rings you received. You are always welcome to return it for an exchange or for a full refund. We are glad that everything is sorted now. We are putting very much effort when it comes to the quality of our products and our services in general.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Loved the ring, until it turned my finger green. Requested a new one about 2 months ago and sent a second one a week ago. Haven't heard from them and just irritated in the lack of response, in addition to the quality. Would just like a new ring to replace this one, as long as it doesn't turn my finger green.
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Mattison,
Our Return Policy highlights that our jewelry has a 1-month period warranty. Since it’s been 4+ months since your package was delivered, it’s no longer eligible for this warranty.
We are really sorry to hear your ring has caused a green discoloration, we know how frustrating this can be. However, it is, unfortunately, a common complaint caused by the copper present in all sterling silver jewelry. This can be especially common in hot, humid climates as moisture in the air or skin can make the copper react in this way.
Since we do not have proof that you have made a complaint within the 30-day warranty period and you haven't sent pictures of the mentioned issue we couldn't proceed otherwise.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Disappointed with the products. I had gotten a raw moonstone ring and the stone fell out within 3 months. Purchased a new one and that stone is about to fall out. I also had purchased a raw rose quartz ring and that stone fell out within weeks. I loved wearing them and they are such pretty rings but not worth It.
Hello Ana,
Thank you for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We appreciate your honesty and are taking all customer feedback (both positive and negative) seriously. While we do clearly state our 30-day warranty policy on our website, we work with each customer individually to find a solution to their issue if that time frame has passed. We stand behind our products and are dedicated to finding an equitable outcome for each shopper on a case-by-case basis.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Not only did shipping take 2 months, customer service refused to care, just saying its not their fault. Usually a company would do what they can to make it right, this company couldn't even make a claim with the courier until the 8 week mark. Xmas came and went with no sign of this ring that I bought at start of November for my sister. She had already left the country by the time it finally arrived mid January. I asked if they could take it back but no, I would have to pay international freight, they wouldn't even ship it back to them despite knowing the situation.
The ring looks like it's been chipped, there's a white spot in the centre of it. Do they not even quality control the cuts?
The gift bag I bought is crinkled and too small for the scratched up little box provided for the ring.
Absolutely do not recommend wasting your money. The company is great at marketing but cannot follow through.
Tip for consumers:
Order 3 months before u need it to avoid disappointment
Products used:
None..I have a worthless item sitting on my bench and I don't know what to do with it
Hello Kat,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are truly sorry to hear that you had trouble with getting your order.
Our sincere apologies on the behalf of the carrier that the shipment was delayed due to the COVID restrictions, but we are happy it wasn't lost, but delivered.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution regarding the ring you received.
Your feedback helps us do better. We are looking into this issue and hope to resolve it promptly and accurately.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I was really excited about purchasing my first piece from Moon Magic, I'm in Australia and their website said 10-15 days postage. With Covid-19 I assumed there would be a little delay and read on their website again expect maybe 3 days longer wait.
However it's now been 6 weeks and I've not received my ring. Contacted their customer service last week with no response... emailed again this week and received what seems to be a generic email just with my name added to it, requesting I provide my order number even though the subject clearly stated my order number.
Contacted DHL and Australia post they've both replied and advised I need to speak with Moon Magic.
I'm highly disappointed spending over $100 AUD on a ring that I'll probably never receive.
Wish I had read these reviews prior to purchasing.
They emailed me weeks ago asking me to post a review, my review was that I'd love to say it's amazing but I've not received it... they've not posted my review nor contacted me.
I ordered the rose gold ring twice. First time the ring discoloured like it was oxidised, so I contacted customer care who suggested to send a new ring. After a couple of months, the rose gold started peeling off. It's a shame because the stones are beautiful and the overall look is gorgeous. I really didn't want to leave a bad review since customer care has been great and the designs of the jewels are gorgeous but the metal is not gold and now I have two discoloured rings. The first image is of my current ring and the second is my initial ring. The oxidisation isn't clearly visible but it has spread throughout the ring, sadly.
Tip for consumers:
In my experience, rose gold/gold colours come off. The silver is better but they do oxidise so you must take care of the metal to prevent that
Hello Zahra,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. Everybody loves a success story, but it’s the not so sparkly reviews that help us learn and improve. We welcome feedback from EVERY customer and use those insights to make the Moon Magic community better for everyone. We connect with customers privately to discuss their individual experiences, and to find equitable solutions for any problem that may arise.
Please, read our very helpful blog on why jewelry can tarnish: https://moonmagic.com/blogs/news/tarnished-jewelry
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I am not one to usually complain however I am extremely upset with the quality of their rings. My partner purchased a ring for me as a gift, this ring lost multiple gems in the first 1-2 weeks of me wearing it. They would not offer a refund, only a replacement of the same right or another of the same value... My replacement ring of the same style, had the exact same loss of gems in the same short amount of time. I then decided to choose a different ring as that replacement and pay the extra difference thinking it might just be that style. But no... my third replacement ring not only lost it's smaller gems but it's main stone too! Please keep in mind I am not rough with my hands what so ever and I have multiple rings from Pandora ect... that I have never had issues with. While their customer service was fine and quick in responding, I would not bother with their jewellery again! Ever
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Eryn,
Thank you for sharing your honest insights with the Moon Magic community. We take every review seriously, and continuously work to improve. Unfortunately, your issues with our jewelry surprise us as well. We stand behind our products and strive to make every bad situation right. Please accept our apologies for any disappointment your Moon Magic experience may have caused. We work hard to meet and exceed our customers’ expectations and bring a little bit of magic into their daily lives!
Warm Regards and Happy Holidays,
Moon Magic
Got two rings from moon magic. Was supposed to be a Christmas gift from my boyfriend but showed up a month after Christmas even thought he ordered a month before Christmas.
I wore moon magic rings sometimes, but apparently too much. The stones on both fell out in under a year.
Their Instagram deletes any negative comments. So many left bad comments and I was shocked that they could sell 85$ plus rings that don't stay in and it wasn't just me. I reached out to them and they pretty much told me tough luck. Same response of when my boyfriend complained for them being a month late. Don't get scammed
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Allison,
Thank you for your Moon Magic purchase and honest feedback. We strive to ensure every item meets your expectations, and acknowledge that sometimes we fall short. Our 30-day warranty is designed to cover manufacturer defects. If a piece is worn beyond that timeframe, signs of use may prevent it from being eligible for return or exchange.
We welcome feedback of all types and use your comments and reviews to continually improve. The bulk of our customer service goes on behind the scenes, and we work with each customer individually to resolve issues if they arise.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I was eyeing moon magic jewelry for a while. I had my heart set on a specific ring. My friend ordered our mutual friend a necklace for christmas last year and had an amazing experience and fast shipping. They also got a ring with a great experience.
My boyfriend bought me my ring back in July for our 3 year anniversary. It was beautiful. I wore it on occasion and sometimes during work ( work from home desk job). This week; i wore it out to my chiropractor appointment then to the pharmacy. At the pharmacy i noticed one of the side stones was missing! My stomach dropped. I was so upset.
I contacted them and they got back to me quickly. Just to find out theres a 1 month warranty. Really? Its not like i was thrashing my hand around or abusing the ring. The prongs arent bent or damaged at all. Their offer was a 10% discount on buying a new ring?
So spend 100+ again for a ring to barely last 6 months? I dont think so. Im so disappointed and heart broken. I LOVED this ring.
Products used:
Lania Ring opal
Hello Alaina,
Thank you for sharing your insights with the Moon Magic community. We appreciate your honesty and are taking all customer feedback (both positive and negative) seriously. While we do clearly state our 30-day warranty policy on our website, we work with each customer individually to find a solution to their issue if that time frame has passed. We stand behind our products and are dedicated to finding an equitable outcome for each shopper on a case-by-case basis.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Moon Magic was very easy to work with! They were very friendly and the exchange process was super easy! Not only did they fix my sizing issues but my rings are very beautiful as well! I will be buying from again on the future.
Hello Karen,
Thank you very much for your kind review. We really appreciate you being a loyal customer and helping to share the word about us. We’re here for you anytime.
All the best,
Moon Magic
I'm so upset. I've order from them once before and was so happy with my purchase. I recently reordered the ring that I originally purchased due to it being stolen. With my second order the ring arrived with missing diamonds, and had black spots all over it. The ring looked terrible. I reached out to customer service and sent pictures of the ring. They issued a replacement, well... I got the replacement today and the ring is just as damaged as the last one! I do not believe they are inspecting these items before they sent them to customers. I honestly believe that they're just boxing these items and not giving a hoot about the customers. Then have the nerve to make the ring go from $49 to $99. The ring should be worth $7 at this point. I will attach photos of the original ring and the damage replacement. I will never shop here again... and to think my soon to be brother in law just ordered a ring from here. Goodness!
Products used:
Rings
Hello Shacari,
At Moon Magic, we’re dedicated to making sure every customer has a 5-star experience. Of course, it’s easy when everything goes right with your order. In business, quality control issues, and returns truly test a customer service team. We acknowledge that mistakes can happen, and we strive to make it right with each customer individually. Yes, we have thousands of verified 5-star reviews, but the not so sparkly customer feedback is just as important to us. We are constantly learning, growing, and improving thanks to your feedback. We are listening and are diligently working behind the scenes to make every shopper’s experience 100% positive.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Very positive experience purchasing my first order with Moon Magic. I was impressed with the delivery time given I live in Australia and even more impressed seeing the rings when they arrived. They are stunning and fit just perfectly and i love the unique designs.
Thank you MM. I'll be shopping with you again soon
Hello Karla,
Thank you for your review, we truly appreciate it. We're very glad to hear that you had a positive experience with our company and that you love your jewelry!
All the best,
Moon Magic
Since 2016, our mission has been to design jewelry that is as powerful and meaningful as the ones who wear it.
We believe that everyone deserves jewelry that goes beyond the surface. That’s why we handpick each gemstone not just for its beautiful gleam, but for its unique energy and potential for self-expression and healing.
✓ We use 100% authentic, ethically sourced gemstones that are independently tested by GIA (Gemological Institute Of America)
✓ Each piece is designed right here in-house, ensuring nothing but originality in every piece
✓ When it comes to quality, we don't compromise - we use the finest premium metals & have a strict quality control in place
✓ 1.8+ million followers across socials & 500k customers and counting...
✓ Beautiful, gift-ready packaging
Note from our founder - Laura:
Since 2016, Moon Magic has been creating beautiful, high-quality, and affordable jewelry that taps into the powerful energies of gems. Our pieces are not just accessories, but soulful companions designed to resonate with your inner spirit while having a modern style.
Whether you're seeking enhanced intuition, greater self-love, or a confidence boost - our jewelry is created to help you flourish. Consciously handpicked and carefully crafted, each gem offers energizing properties to enrich and beautify your daily life.
We hope the radiant glow of our gems serves you as a reminder of the incredible magic around and especially within you.
Sent with love, from our hands and hearts to yours.
With Love & Magic,
Laura
Hello Shari,
We appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review and we are really sorry that you are not satisfied with your experience.
Your order has been reshipped in the meantime and has been delivered. We hope that you are satisfied with your order.
Please reconnect with our customer service for any questions you might have. Thank you for your patience and understanding!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic