• Shane Co.

Shane Co.

Is this your business?
Write a Review

Overview

Shane Co. has a rating of 2.7 stars from 33 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Shane Co. ranks 21st among Diamond sites.

  • Service
    11
  • Value
    11
  • Shipping
    8
  • Returns
    9
  • Quality
    11
Positive reviews (last 12 months): 0%
Positive
0
Neutral
0
Negative
1
3
See all photos
How would you rate Shane Co.?
Top Positive Review

“Amazing”

David T.
1/18/21

I love to woo my girlfriend with presents. And one of her favorite stuff is jewelry. I think every lady like this. So why did i choose this service? They have very beautiful jewelry, any woman will be happy to get such a gift from her man. So if guys you don't know how to surprise your girlfriends - you can browse this site

Top Critical Review

“Lifetime Warrenty is not real”

Nick W.
11/20/23

We got married in mexico and we went to take pictures in the ocean with the photographer, long story short the ring slipped off and could not be found. We were very sad but I thought "lifetime warrenty" no need to worry. To my great surprise when we got back and I called them they told me loss and theft are not covered but I was never told of this it was always "lifetime warrenty" and we cover everything. The sales person I talked to sends me a 400 page coverage and highlighted on page 231 states loss and theft are not covered. Had I been given this information up front and it was not hidden I would of went elsewhere and got twice the diamond size for half the price I paid a premium because if the "lifetime warrenty" expecting them to cover my butt. Please please go elsewhere. Diamonds of better quality and cheaper in almost any other diamond store I just got suckered into the "lifetime warrenty". Please don't make the same mistake I did l!

Reviews (33)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Thumbnail of user davidt200
District of Columbia
7 reviews
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 18th, 2021

I love to woo my girlfriend with presents. And one of her favorite stuff is jewelry. I think every lady like this. So why did i choose this service? They have very beautiful jewelry, any woman will be happy to get such a gift from her man. So if guys you don't know how to surprise your girlfriends - you can browse this site

Thumbnail of user kellin10
Washington
4 reviews
47 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 8th, 2016

Had some issues with follow through on a wedding band. Ball got dropped quite a few times. What I wanted to say was their customer service made it all good, actually they went way over and above what I would have ever expected of any company. They sent me a gift card equal to the value of the ring that I had ordered. It was extremely generous.

Doing it right

Thumbnail of user petera103
Germany
1 review
9 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 25th, 2017

A place for me to search for birthday gifts for some people ;) Its just that easy - you find the thing you need and then make a decision whether to get it here or go to your local store. The delivery is fast and safe, never had problems, though the prices can sometimes be too high.

Thumbnail of user dgon.4177
Mexico
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 20th, 2023

We got married in mexico and we went to take pictures in the ocean with the photographer, long story short the ring slipped off and could not be found. We were very sad but I thought "lifetime warrenty" no need to worry. To my great surprise when we got back and I called them they told me loss and theft are not covered but I was never told of this it was always "lifetime warrenty" and we cover everything. The sales person I talked to sends me a 400 page coverage and highlighted on page 231 states loss and theft are not covered. Had I been given this information up front and it was not hidden I would of went elsewhere and got twice the diamond size for half the price I paid a premium because if the "lifetime warrenty" expecting them to cover my butt. Please please go elsewhere. Diamonds of better quality and cheaper in almost any other diamond store I just got suckered into the "lifetime warrenty". Please don't make the same mistake I did l!

Thumbnail of user vanessaj16
North Carolina
2 reviews
24 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 9th, 2016

My boyfriend ordered me a ring here. I must admit it looked amazing, very nicely done piece of jewelry. However when I decided to purchase a gift for my friend on your website I faced many problems. The website is not very convenient, it is hard to find a delivery information, support team is always offline, not available for chat, the phone line is not responding as well. You should think about improving your service

Thumbnail of user brendal870
Washington
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 26th, 2021

I brought back my ruby diamond ring to the Shane co. Last week (purchased in 2008) One the prongs was bent. I had the best customer service and no BS! I had my ring back to me within 1 week. It's absolutely gorgeous! I will never buy jewelry again from Costco. I'm sold on the Shane Co. Forever. I definitely have a friend in the diamond business! Gold stars for the Shane Co.

Tip for consumers:
Don’t think twice! The Shane company is the best! They stand behind their word

Products used:
Ruby diamond ring (2008)

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user margarets262
California
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 9th, 2018

The service is great! Fast delivery and a huge Collection of jewellery. Very beautiful design Rings, Earring and Necklace are there. I love it Very much. This the site that I recommend everybody to try.

Thumbnail of user yazminb1
California
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 26th, 2022

I brought in my daughter necklace tangle ( is the last gift she received from him! He passed on Dec 2021. Jamie the jeweler did awesome in less than 5 minutes was done! Thank you guys! And awesome Matthew was awesome

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user kristinp58
Georgia
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 25th, 2019

This place has pretty much ruined my wedding day considering I even had to get married without my real ring and although they had me a loner ring it just wasnt the same. I waited 12 wks or longer on my ring that was supposed to take 6-8 wks i was very disappointed. We decided to go to Jared and they took care of me right away

Thumbnail of user reesed28
Mississippi
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 13th, 2021

I was very nervous when going and buying my engagement ring for my fiancé. The manager Charles was amazing and so helpful, he immediately gave me reassurance that I could do this and walked me through every step of the way and taught me everything I needed to know step by step. Whenever I come back to this location I will be sure to ask for Charles. 10/10 better experience than I was expecting. Cannot recommend enough!

Products used:
Engagement ring

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user davids7653
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 2nd, 2022

I was just at the Shane Company in Alpharetta Ga a few minutes ago - today - Weds, March 2nd 2022 at 1230 pm. I met with a representative there named Robert. I think his name tag said Ocala Florida.

Robert greeted me when I came in right away. I explained that I had a pair of earrings I had purchased there that backs kept coming off. I also had an anklet of my girlfriend's that the clasp broke. It was not purchased there.

Robert took both items back and promptly repaired and cleaned both! Even the anklet that had not been purchased there.

Robert said that happy customers is the reason people keep coming back. And good reviews like this one mean everything to Tom Shane.

Well. Let me tell you. I love the Shane Company. I have purchased MANY pieces of jewelry there. I would never even consider shopping anywhere else.

Let me end this review by saying - I'm a Shane Company customer for life!

Thanks.

David Strickland
Cumming Ga.

Tip for consumers:
Shane Company - great service after the sale!

Products used:
Jewelry

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user katinas
California
10 reviews
66 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 28th, 2014

I bought my sapphire wedding ring from shane company and it was the best ring ever. My friends all love it and it was only around $4000 for a huge sapphire. I ordered just the gemstone alone online. It was certified and I had it appraised and it was the real deal. It would have cost me almost twice as much from other retail stores I was looking at.

Thumbnail of user deliaj17
Missouri
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 2nd, 2022

I love and trust the Shane Company. I will not let any other jeweler work on my rings. They are very trustworthy and have quality. I like that I can trade my Diamond in for a better quality and get the full value I paid for my old Diamond. They helped me pick the right Diamond for my budget.

Tip for consumers:
Pearls are not upgraded only the diamonds maintain there value to trade up for better wuality

Products used:
Ring for 30th anniversary and then 50th anniversary

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user sherriep52
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 5th, 2023
Verified purchase

Arleen and Dylan took great care of my husband and me. We got exactly what we wanted. They cleaned all my jewelry while we waited. We left my broken ring, one bought at a different jewelry store, and they fixed it so beautifully. You cannot even tell it was broken. They also polished it, so it sparkled magnificently. I got so many compliments. Also, on both occasions the ladies and the Service Desk were so helpful and sweet. Everyone even the security guard were very attentive and helpful.

Thumbnail of user lisap3178
Utah
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 6th, 2023

I sent my 3 boys here to buy wedding ring. My daughter recently got engaged and i wanted a necklace and earrings that matched her ring. Even though Shane Co was more expensive I thought they had good service, THOUGHT WRONG! Chatted online with sales person, completed the purchase, paid for it and waited for it to show up. I received a call the next day asking for a email which i provided. Purchase clears my banking so I assume it's on the way. 5 days later I get an email at the email address they claim they can't verify that my order was cancelled. I called the store, didn't even give them a name, acct number nothing but they knew exactly what i was talking about. Yup they canceled my paid order. I'm now stuck wedding day tomorrow and no precious gift. I asked why they couldn't simply call and ask i kept hearing was they couldn't verify my email ‍needless to say, never shopping here again

Products used:
nothing, apparently they don’t sell to people who have my email address

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user ts738
Illinois
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
January 14th, 2022

I purchased a diamond ring from Shane last summer. After making the last payment I went to pick it up. Before leaving I asked them to verify the serial number on the diamond and discovered it was not the one I had purchased. After further investigation I found out Shane had sold my diamond to another customer and the one they delivered to me was of substantially lower quality and lower value. When I asked if it was standard policy that they check serial numbers before setting and delivery, they said no. All other jewelers I have since visited said it was standard policy. I demanded my money back and found a ring at another jeweler. The moral of this story is find a jeweler you trust. If you bought from Shane before reading this, make sure the serial numbers on your diamonds match what you purchased. Note: for this review, there is no selection for zero stars. Since then Shaneco posted a response saying management would contact me to help resolve the issue and we have heard nothing.

Products used:
Jewelry

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user dougb450
Colorado
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 22nd, 2021

Ordered present for wife at Christmas. Promised two day delivery. Never happened. Waited all day at house. Was informed at 6:00 PM tnat it was not going to make it and would have to wait an additional day to see of it makes. Called customer service amd their answer was basically too nad so sad. Will mever do business woth company again!

Thumbnail of user pamt32
Minnesota
1 review
10 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 15th, 2017

Just had my diamond reset. It looks like a gum ball ring. I loved my diamond and setting and couldn't wait to get it back. It looks like a different ring I hate it now! It's shorter and doesn't look very pretty I'm so mad! I hate this place so much! Avoid avoid avoid!

Thumbnail of user breeg19
Massachusetts
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 9th, 2022
Verified purchase

I convinced my friend to go to a jewelers to address the PILE of jewelry related tasks that she'd been sitting on for some 20 years: resizing, remounting, cleaning, appraising, selling, and Shane Co was the only local jeweler open on a Sunday. We kept our consultant, Zach Sibal, very busy running around as we browsed the showroom for potential settings. He not only professionally dealt with every task and question we threw at him (and we kept thinking of more!), he also very sensitively responded to my friend dealing with the difficult emotions of her late husband's engagement ring. We left with all her jewelry fastidiously cleaned, her grandfather's ring left behind for a resizing, and a clear plan on how to pay for and custom remount a diamond, as well as a quick hands on training on how to identify hers from others. We were also warmly greeted, scheduled, and checked out by Georgia Carin, another great employee. Couldn't ask for a better experience.

Products used:
Jewelery resizing

Service
Value
Quality
Thumbnail of user sandrag34
Philippines
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
September 25th, 2015

I've been trying to buy a necklace for about a week now. My card has sufficient funds but they seem to keep cancelling my order! So fed up! Taking my business to Blue Nile instead.

Thumbnail of user barbaraa1835
Indiana
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
July 1st, 2023

I wrote to Tom Shane and no reply... Shane has had my ring for a simple repair of just putting stone back in for over 6 months. I still do not have my ring back. They have had it since January.
Shane's repair and customer service is not very customer friendly. I have my original receipt for my ring and shane did not want to fix it, and tried to get out of it. I was told I have a lifetime warranty to fix it. I have my original receipt. They finally said they would put the stone back in. Now it needs remade, when I call in, I get different stories about where it is. 2 months ago, I was told the vendor would be done in 2 days, then quality control and I would have it in a a week---not so. I have been told it is in Denver, then it is out of the country, but we do not know where in the world it is. I have been told by Caleb, that since shane is fixing it for free that I do not have a right to complain or be concerned it is taking over 6 months and I still do not have it. It is do not call us we will call you. Every time they say they will call about something, they do not call. I cannot depend on getting a call from someone so undependable. A lot of my friends and family know the story and are convinced my ring has been lost and they just have not told me yet.

Products used:
ring--- jewelry

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user kirkh166
Georgia
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 29th, 2022
Verified purchase

I got my wife's bridal set sized and had the diamond I bought put it.
Csr was very condescending bad

Products used:
Bridal set

Thumbnail of user tawnyb9
Minnesota
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
August 18th, 2021

My husband and I both got our rings here, everytime we need service done to our rings, the customer service and turnout time is awful!

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user elaineh121
Washington
1 review
22 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 26th, 2019

Maybe my expectations are too high since everybody else seems to be ok with getting bad service from ignorant staff. I have been to the Westminster store twice in the last month and it is obvious they are under staffed. Maybe they need to consider why that is and pay their people better. Jewely has a mark up of 3 to 4 times cost and since I have worked at a jewelry store before, I know they make BANK. Anyway, after selecting my item, I was left in line at the cashier area where only one cashier was working and already helping a couple. There was one other person in front of me in line. I stood there for several minutes while the only cashier answered question after question from the couple she was helping, meanwhile the phone rang and three additional customers accumulated behind me. She answered the phone while helping the same folks she had been with during this entire episode and it went like this, "No she is out on a break right now, I can take your number and have her call you back when she returns or you can try back in about 30 minutes if you like and she should be back by then. Oh, well I can help you with that, let me finish with the customer I have in front of me and I will be right back with you." She puts them on hold, finishes up with current customer (which has been taking at least 10 minutes) then gets back on the phone. Nevermind that she has six other customers that have been waiting in line since BEFORE the phone call came in. Who trained this ignorant soul? The customer in front of you is your most important focus. She very easily could have told the phone call that she had several other customers in line ahead of them and she would be happy to call them back at her ealiest availability. At no point in time did she ever look up at us in line or acknowledge us in any way. So here is how it ended, she was still on the phone while we all waited until her coworker came back from break, coworker helped the person in front of me then me then she finally got off the phone and that is when I left. Terrible terrible service! People are spending hundreds and thousands of dollars on totally discretionary items and this is how Shane treats his customers.

Thumbnail of user sithenw
Canada
2 reviews
13 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 19th, 2015

I know that Shane co claims to be the 'best in the jewelery business' and that their fifth c is 'customer service' but really, they're the worst non-commission based jewelry store I've been to. They're pushy, they ignore you regularly, they don't have a very good selection

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

About the business

Visit your local Shane Co. jewelry store for the best collection of engagement rings, wedding rings and fine jewelry. Buy risk-free with our 60-day return policy and free lifetime warranty. Experience the difference today.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Shane Co.?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members

See reviews as you browse with our Chrome extension

2.7
33 reviews
Have a question about Shane Co.?

Is this your business?

Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and manage your listing.

Claim Your Business