• CosplayMagic

CosplayMagic

Is this your business?
Write a Review

Overview

CosplayMagic has a rating of 2.4 stars from 34 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. CosplayMagic ranks 57th among Costumes sites.

  • Shipping
    4
  • Quality
    4
See all photos
How would you rate CosplayMagic?
Top Positive Review

“Long time return customer and will be forever!”

Steven C.
8/28/17

I have purchased from Cosplay Magic multiple times since I was about 16... I'm now 23... I have owned many cosplay from them and they've all held up surprisingly well... Even though a TON of wear. My only complaint isn't their fault... The men's pants never fit me but I have wider hips. Female sizing is a little bigger than advertised but men's sizing is spot on! Very happy with this company over the many years I have used them.

Top Critical Review

“Might as well burn your money”

Jake G.
12/10/16

I ordered my custom cosplay for $200, and I might as well have wiped my a** with my money. I WISH I could tell you how my cosplay was, but I never received it; after waiting two months with no communication from the site, they shipped it to someone else in a city two hours away from me. I contacted everyone involved and they were all just like "don't look at me." Whatever.

Reviews (34)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

costume (21)
Thumbnail of user stevenc150
Georgia
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
August 28th, 2017

I have purchased from Cosplay Magic multiple times since I was about 16... I'm now 23... I have owned many cosplay from them and they've all held up surprisingly well... Even though a TON of wear. My only complaint isn't their fault... The men's pants never fit me but I have wider hips. Female sizing is a little bigger than advertised but men's sizing is spot on! Very happy with this company over the many years I have used them.

Thumbnail of user sonyad8
Canada
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
March 31st, 2017

Honestly just follow the size guide and you should be okay. Allow yourself an extra inch if possible - especially if you have a couple months to go till your con. I got my order within 3 weeks of ordering and everything looks really good! The only thing I can complain about if that the tunic for one of them was supposed to be kind of like a dress and it barely covers my butt. Otherwise I'm so happy with what I got and was really impressed by the quality of material and that the sizes were true to the guide.

Thumbnail of user jakeg24
Connecticut
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 10th, 2016

I ordered my custom cosplay for $200, and I might as well have wiped my a** with my money. I WISH I could tell you how my cosplay was, but I never received it; after waiting two months with no communication from the site, they shipped it to someone else in a city two hours away from me. I contacted everyone involved and they were all just like "don't look at me."

Whatever.

Thumbnail of user sarahm24
Belgium
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
April 16th, 2012

I did buy a wig there.
The wig was quite expensive and it was very poor quality!
There was almost no hair on it!
Seemed not at all like the picture!
Stay away from cosplay magic. You only will lose money!

Thumbnail of user jennyh4
Hong Kong
1 review
4 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 12th, 2011

After waited for almost 2months now and emailed them over 10+ times with little or no responds, I still haven't get my order which i paid $190 for! They are totally a scam and ridiculous to do business with. Do not buy from them unless you want troubles!

Thumbnail of user paganc1
Italy
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 10th, 2020

I decided to try this website for the first time as I thought their wig was the perfect one for my cosplay. After almost two months of waiting (which was not expected, since they promised me a maximum of 20 days and I received all of my other cosplay orders well before theirs) I received a package that was damaged on the outside, but not on the inside luckily. The wig itself has very high quality fibers, but does not look like the one on their website. I will make it work and the difference is not drastic, but still it was another red flag. The customer support was kinda helpful, even though not very friendly. Overall I would not buy again from them and would not recommend this website, too many uncertaintes, the products are probably overpriced and the free shipping was very late. I was expecting something better overall, so shop here at your own risk and only if you have no other options, I had a way better experience with AliExpress to be honest.

Thumbnail of user jemc3
Australia
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 28th, 2017

Whenever I needed information and would email them they would get back to me quickly with the correct information which was a huge relief.
The costume came in the mail about a week after they had shipped it out - the fast shipping was so fantastic and nothing had been damaged on the way over here.
The costume itself was so wonderfully put together. The only issue I had was with some of the detail where nothing had been cut in a straight line and seemed kind of sloppy. For the price of the costume the least I expected was a bit of care taken with the details.
However, overall I'm very happy with my purchase and will definitely buy from Cosplay Magic again!

Thumbnail of user juliettec
Italy
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 30th, 2016

I got the Assassin's Creed Syndicate Evie cosplay. The shipping was fast, but the service was kind of awful. When the costume arrived it looked nice, but was a bit smaller than I liked. I've already read that returning it for a bigger size would be a huge hassle so I didn't. A week before the con I went to, buttons started popping off of it, I sewed all of them back on giving it the benefit of the doubt that I was just a little to active when testing it out. Then the zipper from the undershirt came off and while at the con, I lost four buttons, I'm going to have to replace the whole set and the zipper! Long story short, I'm not buying from them again.

Thumbnail of user micob
Italy
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 2nd, 2015

I ordered a Killer Bee cosplay from Cosplaymagic.com, it look exactly like in the picture on the website, the quality it's very nice, i live in Rome i received around 6 days from ordering, I recommend you to take one size smaller, so if you are L take the M size. ;)

Tip for consumers:
I recommend you to take one size smaller, so if you are L take the M size. ;)

Service
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user glennm41
Netherlands
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 29th, 2013

Ordered an Ulquiorra cosplay costume and Wig during Chinese new year.
I was concerned the order might be delayed due to it so I sent an email regarding the matter. I received word back 2 days afterwards stating that indeed due to Chinese New Year orders are set back and I'd have to receive the costume within the next week as operations had resumed again.
About 3 days later I received the outfit.
Outfit and Wig were exactly as what you could see from the website photo's.
Great company, would buy from them again.

Thumbnail of user lisar5
GB
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 9th, 2013

Bad experience - costume sizes are completely in accurate, had to return the costume at my expence of £15.00, then when i asked for a refund it was £25.00 less than the cost, to cover them shipping it to me. What a joke! £40.00 shipping cost to me - never again

Thumbnail of user am245
Netherlands
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
August 14th, 2018

My experience was excellent!
Today 14-08-2018.
Customer support within 24 hours.
Reply's within 1 hours.
After payment within 60 hours my package arrived (hong-kong to netherlands)
Costume exact as in the pictures!
Quality 10/10!

Thumbnail of user brookm2
Canada
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 16th, 2017

I so naively ignored the warnings of other reviews and decided to try this site out. It hasn't been 5 days and red flags are jumping up everywhere. I ordered an Inuyasha cosplay outfit for 103.00$. So, besides being overpriced, there were hidden fees I was not told about dropped on me as they took the money from my master card. About, 42.76$ more than anticipated. I have emailed them several times and hope to cancel that order before they send me anything. Besides being overpriced, there are other outfits for less that look much better on other, reputable sites. They got 1 star because I couldn't give zero.

Thumbnail of user robertleyy
Australia
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
February 22nd, 2017

The costume that I ordered arrived in 7 days while I'm in Western Australia! While the picture that shows the products looks exactly what you get. Definitely coming back to that site!

And thanks to them I've got costume in madman 2017!

Thumbnail of user seanm79
GB
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 23rd, 2015

I ordered a cosplay wig and Kunai for a Naruto Haku cosplay back in early may(Priority Airmail also) And make a specific request to have it asap. It is now late August and it says the product was shipped. I never received the product, nor have I had any words from the so-called-retailer. I have e-mailed them but not received a response. I spent $59 on this order, and have not even been given the option of a refund. Totally pathetic, avoid at all costs.

Thumbnail of user kwonx
Michigan
7 reviews
22 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 5th, 2012

Unfortunately, my experiences with CosplayMagic have yielded exceedingly poor fabric choice and lackluster quality in both appearance and longevity. However, while not necessarily true, many con fans will point out the differences between costumes and cosplay when it comes to the quality and authenticity of their outfits. And this site is sadly just another one of those cheap shops that mass produce junk.

At least from my previous encounters with them, their Jin Kazama and Jin (Samurai Champloo) outfits were atrocious. I actually burned them, knowing that the world's better off with those two pieces of work flamed from existence. Lessons learned, people.

Thumbnail of user jodir7
Canada
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
May 26th, 2015

I've gotten two costumes from Cosplay Magic; Tsubasa Sakura, and Mikasa Ackerman's scouting uniform. The Sakura one was great, needed little to no adjusting. Mikasa's... not so much. The hood of the cape is literally the size of my torso. The pants are too big, but the belt is too small, but the hip wrap skirt is perfect. The blouse and jacket are both too long in the sleeves, but I knew that might happen because I'm kind of short. The real $#*!ery came when I tried to put on the harness. I'm fairly certain that this harness was designed for a 5 meter Titan, because it sure as hell doesn't fit a 5' tall woman.

Thumbnail of user yuweil
New Jersey
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
June 15th, 2018

Cos
I bought a costume in this shoptheir costume have great difference between the original costume, the original costume is white but they sent me a grey one, use the spot goods to pretend they are costomize and asked me for costume fee, and the quality is very poor, contacted them they just ignore you and does not reply, very bad service attitude, don't buy anything in this shop

Thumbnail of user heathers50
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 27th, 2014

I ordered a Sango Battle Costume and was overall pleased with it. I did some alterations to it to make it more practical to wear around but was overall pleased. I received the order in about 4 days from when I ordered it. I was also sent a text by the delivery company telling me when it would be delivered.

Thumbnail of user lucyl56
Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 23rd, 2017

My son costume come so fast it come in a week and it looks great I paid $130.00 for the black butler the joker thank you so much my son is a big boy but this costume is way way to big I got him a x5 large but I'm happy because I have ordered really big before from other stores and it was not big enough so please measure yourself before you order from them they was so nice they emailed me to ask if I was sure I wanted it so big

Thumbnail of user joshuas104
Nevada
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
October 12th, 2017

I received my costume in roughly 7 business days and it fits as if it were tailor made for me not to mention all of the stitching looks great and it's lined (which I was not expecting).

Thumbnail of user marcellab
Michigan
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 14th, 2014

After comparing all the sites and costumes, I chose Cosplaymagic. I ordered my daughters costume (Ouran High School Host Club Boy Uniform) on Saturday the 11th. I was worried I wouldn't get it for Halloween, but received it Tuesday the 14th. Fantastic! Great quality. I was expecting junk, but not the case at all. Size was good too. I will definitely use Cosplaymagic again.
I think everyone needs to read the information on the product and understand. If the price was cheap, the costume will be cheap. I on the other hand ordered the good one and got the good one. Nice!

Tip for consumers:
Always check the delivery dates before you purchase.

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user caseyw98
Ohio
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 27th, 2020

Ordered April 17th and it was sent out within a week! I paid for fast shipping and it came within 4 days!
Great quality cosplay and looked exactly as pictured.

Thumbnail of user mickb22
Minnesota
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 12th, 2017

I purchased a Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen wedding dress costume for an upcoming Halloween party. I had an issue with my card upon checkout and sent an email message to the customer service department, hoping to hear back from them within a day or two to get it resolved. I was amazed to receive a response within a few minutes - especially since it was about 12:30am. The customer service representative handled my issue promptly and professionally (even making a last-minute adjustment for me), and informed me that I should receive my items in approximately 10 days.
I was surprised to see my order show up in only 6 days. When I opened the parcel, I was extremely impressed with the quality of the costumes. I somewhat expected it to look different than the picture on the site, but that wasn't the case at all. It exceeded my expectations in every way - high quality material with sturdy fasteners, and it fit very well (their sizing chart is very accurate). They definitely paid attention to detail in the design of both of these costumes as they look amazing when worn. Note: The Jon Snow costume is very warm so keep that in mind if you intend to wear it somewhere that the temperatures are on the high side.
My experience was very positive and I wouldn't hesitate purchasing from them in the future.

Thumbnail of user jaspers33
Washington
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 20th, 2018

So I ended up ordering a magilou from tales of berseria cosplay. When I ordered this I already knew that I was gonna edit out stuff I wasnt particularly happy about myself and just use it all as a base (her outfit is pretty complicated). Well I had bought the item around my birthday and then my friend ended up telling me they were gonna make me it and help me as a gift. Yikes. So I email them really quick HOPING there was a chance that I could get it canceled because PayPal wouldnt let me. Note that this was all in the same day that I bought it. I think I wrote at least 5 emails to them. To which they NEVER responded. At about 2 weeks I ended up actually forgetting about it. Live and learn you know? But then I ended up getting the cosplay in the mail... I was so confused honestly. But whatever roll with what you got. So I open everything and its honestly really great work... stitching is beautiful details are nice but the only problem... and heres the funny part. Well. Im a petite x small girl. And I ordered x small. Everything that came with her cosplay is an extra small. The tights, the arm bands, the shorts... hell even the hat has a small head. But the main top is literally large. Its so big on me that I can fit another person. At first I was angry, and then it turned into funny like how do you $#*! up that one thing? So bad? But I decided to email them asking for a replacement. Hey if I have the cosplay in my hands might as well use it. But I highly doubt they will reply to me considering I didnt even KNOW it was shipped out or that I would get it. Literally they never updated my order. And I had nice shipping too! Yikes! My favorite part is that I even messaged them on Facebook about it. I didnt even say I wanted the whole cosplay replaced. Just the top and they saw my message and didnt reply. Kinda laughable at this point at customer service but hey at least I can fix the issue myself sort of. So just be wary!

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

About the business

Cosplay Magic is the most recognized cosplay store which offers best quality cosplay from japanese anime, cosplay from video games and cosplay from movies. You can shop cosplay costumes for halloween or cosplay costumes for all kinds of event.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about CosplayMagic?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about CosplayMagic?

Is this your business?

Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and manage your listing.

Claim Your Business