• CosplayMagic

CosplayMagic

Is this your business?
Write a Review

Overview

CosplayMagic has a rating of 2.4 stars from 34 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. CosplayMagic ranks 202nd among Costumes sites.

  • Shipping
    4
  • Quality
    4
See all photos
How would you rate CosplayMagic?
Top Positive Review

“Long time return customer and will be forever!”

Steven C.
8/28/17

I have purchased from Cosplay Magic multiple times since I was about 16... I'm now 23... I have owned many cosplay from them and they've all held up surprisingly well... Even though a TON of wear. My only complaint isn't their fault... The men's pants never fit me but I have wider hips. Female sizing is a little bigger than advertised but men's sizing is spot on! Very happy with this company over the many years I have used them.

Top Critical Review

“Might as well burn your money”

Jake G.
12/10/16

I ordered my custom cosplay for $200, and I might as well have wiped my a** with my money. I WISH I could tell you how my cosplay was, but I never received it; after waiting two months with no communication from the site, they shipped it to someone else in a city two hours away from me. I contacted everyone involved and they were all just like "don't look at me." Whatever.

Reviews (34)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

costume (21)
Thumbnail of user gemr2
Australia
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 18th, 2019

Paid for express shipping which is 1-3 days. They sent it out in 8. Fine what ever i didnt get it so i returned it they were fine gave me a RAN and everything. Its now 2 weeks no reply no refund no nothing. I even got express tracking return that says its been delivered ages ago. Disputing with paypal at the moment. DO NOT ORDER WITH THIS SITE IF YOU ARE NOT 100% OK WITH THE POSSIBILITY OF LOSING YOUR MONEY scammers i feel. Should be shut down

Thumbnail of user terryh5
Hong Kong
1 review
7 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 9th, 2011

Got my costumes for 2 months waiting, never reply emails, and the costume doesn't look like the picture shown, quality is bad. I don't like this site and beware

Thumbnail of user mateom11
Canada
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
June 2nd, 2016

I'm quite short so I ordered a men's small for a costume. When it arrived everything was WAY to big. None of the things fit me. It did come extremely fast and the costume was high quality.

Thumbnail of user weaq
Switzerland
1 review
4 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 24th, 2017

So i got today my sombra cosplay, and it's waaaay too big! I ordered size S because the size chart said i need that and it's like a L. No really, it's just too big. And i paid 290$ for a costume i have to open up and sew smaller if possible. I also didn't get the costume on the pictue, the pants are not made of faux leather and the armor parts are made of fabric and also not very accurate. Please if you read this invest your money in a other shop you will regret it like me. I spended way less money on aliexpress and got better quality costumes that this... i don't even know how to call it... this mess of fabric sewn together.

Thumbnail of user robinc94
Utah
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 5th, 2017

I read all of the scary warning reviews about this site, but decided to give it a shot. I was wary and anxiety ridden through out the whole thing. I ordered a Kingdom Hearts 3 Sora costume. It shipped out in 11 days, it got to my door in a week. I live in a rural area, so that's pretty good shipping for me. Everything came neatly packaged, each item of clothing in its own baggie- But there was a really weird smell. Letting it hang out side for a few hours did the trick.

Quality wise- It's fairly decent. Everything fits well. The pants are baggy at the bottom like in the video game. But how the red lapel sits on the jacket irritates me, but with a seam ripper I managed to fix it myself. The major complaint is- I absolutely cannot stand the gloves they sent me. They look like they're made out of weird puffy winter jacket material and way too big. You can only see the tips of my fingers sticking out of the glove. Even with the yellow belt tight around it, it's still too big. I won't be wearing them for the con since they look so stupid :(. The zippers on the jacket and pants seems fragile and cheap as well.

So except for three or four complaints to the costume itself, I'm fairly satisfied with it and will be happy to wear it to the con. But not the gloves. To hell with those gloves.

Tip for consumers:
The site does run big. According to their chart, I'm an xl, but I got a large, and it fits very well. Just get a size smaller.

Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user sherlys
Arizona
4 reviews
6 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 30th, 2012

The costume I bought here is very bad in quality. Just a few pieces of thin cloths and nothing like the picture shown. Nothing but bad news here, I wouldn't recommend anyone to buy here at all.

Thumbnail of user saya21
France
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
April 24th, 2017

I saw bad and good reviews and was mixed about getting a Cosplay here, but they looked so nice on the pictures I decided to give it a shot. It was a huge mistake.

I sent my measurements to them and they suggested me the medium size for the Deadpool costume. Paid $180 with free shipping. Received it after a few days only, I was extremely excited about it.
It was /way/ too big. I couldn't even put the pants, I was floating in it and it's fully fall down on the floor.
The jacket had white marker marks all over it.
I decided to resend it to get a refund, and this is when I understood I was getting $#*!ed: they sent me a damaged item that was too big for me even though I gave them my measurements, but /I/ had to pay $60 for the shipping, and they refunded me $151 instead of $180 because they don't refund the shipping (which was FREE on their website.) Terrible customer service, not to mention I paid $35 of taxes for it to almost get delivered in the wrong town. Please don't do the same mistake as me. The cosplay's are terrible, and you'll lose so much money on this.

Thumbnail of user jamiel64
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 5th, 2016

I was looking for a costume to do a genderbend of Naruto. I did my research and cosplaymagic was the site I decided to buy from. I regret it now! I bought a custom made Naruto cosplay costume from them. Gave them all my measurements, made sure they understood that I'm a girl and wanted it form fitting and feminine. Received my costume within 3 weeks and OMG the costume was a complete disaster! You would think this costume would fit me like a glove since I gave them my exact measurements, nope, didn't fit me at all. The thing was huge! As if it was made for a giant man! The jacket was huge, the pants were huge, everything huge! I'll never wear it as is. I contacted them and explained my situation when they told me they do not do refunds on custom made costumes. My argument, not anywhere on their site does it mention no refunds on custom made costumes and this costume wasn't even custom made as it doesn't even fit me at all! I sent them pictures of what the costume looked like on me and I never received another email from them. I got totally screwed. Cost me $250 CAD and I'm stuck with a costume that doesn't fit me and I'll never even be able to wear/use. Do yourself a favor and avoid this site at all cost!

Thumbnail of user joshp299
Vermont
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 4th, 2022

The costume were amazing and it came fast, and wig was pretty good as well, they replied really fast

Products used:
Full costume

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

About the business

Cosplay Magic is the most recognized cosplay store which offers best quality cosplay from japanese anime, cosplay from video games and cosplay from movies. You can shop cosplay costumes for halloween or cosplay costumes for all kinds of event.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about CosplayMagic?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about CosplayMagic?

Is this your business?

Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and manage your listing.

Claim Your Business