• SportsMemorabilia.com

SportsMemorabilia.com

Write a Review

Overview

SportsMemorabilia.com has a rating of 3.6 stars from 652 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with SportsMemorabilia.com most frequently mention customer service, timely manner, and birthday gift. SportsMemorabilia.com ranks 1st among Sports Memorabilia sites.

  • Service
    53
  • Value
    47
  • Quality
    41

This company responds to reviews on average within 12 days

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 66.7%
Positive
2
Neutral
0
Negative
1
23
See all photos
How would you rate SportsMemorabilia.com?
Top Positive Review

“Cristin was great!”

Michael N.
2/8/24

I have purchased before from Sportsmemorabilia and never had any issues. This is my first experience with an issue and Cristin was great! She resolved it quickly and responded quickly! Thanks Cristin.

Top Critical Review

“Buyer Beware”

Jeff K.
6/2/24

I placed an order for one item. They sent me three. I called them immediately. They strung me along for two weeks then told me they wouldn't do a return. I wouldn't recommend this company to anyone

Reviews (652)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

shelby coyle (43) connie hubbard (25) customer service (352)
Thumbnail of user tanyap60
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 29th, 2018

Alexis was amazing! I was worried that my husband's gift would not arrive in time for Christmas- Alexis made sure I had my tracking number and was in touch with me boxing day to ensure that i had my order and all was well.
My husband was amazed! Thank you again for making a very surprised and happy husband!

Thumbnail of user mariat168
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 30th, 2018

Shelby Coyle was able to figure out why my order had not shipped and got back to me that very same day. She was able to figure out the problem and I received my package within a couple of days. She was excellent.

Thumbnail of user davids2913
Canada
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 5th, 2019

Cristin was an absolute superstar in dealing with my order. She was on top of things, quick to respond to calls/emails. She ensured prompt shipping and quickly changed the destination address to my work from home.

Everything was done promptly, courteously and in a professional and friendly manner.

Thumbnail of user farrish3
GB
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
August 25th, 2017

Wanted some items for a party I'm throwing for the Mayweather v McGregor fight and an issue with finding the stock. Donna O'Donnell the customer service agent I spoke to quickly made contact with the warehouse and had my items shipped all together. Everything arrived yesterday in perfect condition and just in time for saturdays big event. Thank you Donna

Thumbnail of user lisam524
New Jersey
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 24th, 2017

Ingrid Padron provided me with excellent customer service! I placed an order for a Signed Jersey as a Christmas present, there was so type of computer error and Ingrid personally did all she could to get me my perfect present! I received the jersey yesterday and it is perfect! She saved my Christmas!

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user ryanw218
Arkansas
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 27th, 2018

I was in a pinch for a Christmas gift to deliver from the site. It had been held up for some reason. I contacted them and got Shelby Coyle. She was very helpful in getting with the warehouse to find the problem, communicated it with me, and got a resolution. She did everything she could to get it to me on time and I couldn't be more appreciative of her efforts.

Thumbnail of user alicep88
Florida
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 15th, 2018

I ordered a ticket stub from the 1983 World Series as a gift on a Friday, and paid for FedEX next day shipping so that I could have it on Monday... But when I was checking out online at 1:40pm, I noticed that it said orders placed after 1 pm would be processed the next business day... I called and got Alexis, who pulled the order, flagged it at the Distribution Center, and made sure it shipped... and I received it Monday morning in time to give it as a gift Monday night. Thanks so much! PS, my friend absolutely loved it!

Thumbnail of user michaelb1648
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 9th, 2019

We ordered our item and had some issues in delivery due to the courier. Shelby went well above and beyond to make sure we got our item with minimum fire and dealt with the issue with the courier. Best customer service I've had in a while, will order again.

Thumbnail of user enriqueg99
Greece
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 1st, 2022

I had an issue with the tracking number of my item, I contacted costumer service and Shakira helped me out all the way until it was resolved.
Her responses were fast, kind and helpul during the entire process.
I can not thank her enough.

Thumbnail of user pedroo21
AE
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 24th, 2018

It's not usual to find the type of support I got from Cristin on an online retailer - one of the reasons I continue to buy in SportsMemorabilia year after year! (I so wish banks and airlines had this level of customer service!)

Thumbnail of user peterc191
Arizona
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 6th, 2017

Had a few issues with confirmation of my international order and, due to Labor Day weekend, had major problems contacting anyone to resolve it. Thankfully, Ingrid Padron was the only person to respond over the weekend and did a fantastic job resolving my queries. Thanks Ingrid - you're a real star!

Thumbnail of user calebb136
Missouri
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 24th, 2022

Cristin was absolutely excellent and fixed my issue in no time. I had received a defective product and Cristin got a replacement sent out to me within the week! On top of that, Cristin was incredibly responsive and provided me with all of the information I needed! Easily one of the best customer service representatives I've had!

Products used:
I used a signed puck and a display case. The display case came with a flaw and that is what Cristin corrected in less than a week. It really meant a lot because it was a birthday present!

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user carolk98
Connecticut
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 12th, 2018

I order something at sportsmemorabilia.com and I had an issue with the estimated shipping. I called the customer service and Thais Evans and Corey Bandremer were amazing in helping me out. They both took charge, solved my issue and were very pleasant and professional. I would recommend buying from them.

Thumbnail of user vanessap80
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
September 20th, 2018

Ordered a signed jersey which came in the mail within 5 days (bonus for Canada)
Customer service was great
I ordered the wrong Jersey at first and cancelling the order was quick and easy.
I worked with Alexis via email and had responses right away
The product is great as well of course :)

Thumbnail of user jeannettem30
Missouri
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 29th, 2019

Purchased a framed autographed NFL photo for my son's 50th birthday on line. The next day photo was priced cheaper. Called and talked with Shelby and she lowered and credit my account with the difference. I was very impressed. Then when I received the photo the frame had a very small scratch on it. Immediately emailed Shelby and she responded with a solution to this issue and I sent back the framed photo and without a lot of delay problem fixed and we were very happy with the final product. Customer service was awesome and I appreciated Shelby very much. Thank you for the great service and I will not hesitate to order again from this company. Sincerely Jeannette

Thumbnail of user melissaf72
Georgia
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 30th, 2017

I needed help finding my hologram for authenticity purposes and used the live chat on the website. Connie Hubbard was my agent and she was wonderful. She was very patient and helped me locate the hologram. Excellent customer service.

Thumbnail of user bethaniem
Maryland
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 8th, 2018

Alexis helped me out when I was curious about shipping dates for my order. She was always available and quick to respond to my questions. She kept in contact with me throughout the shipping and made sure I was satisfied with my purchase!

Thumbnail of user jonib102
Oregon
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 1st, 2021

I ordred a signed framed Bellinger World Series jersey on Aug 16. It took several weeks to arrive which was ok, but when I opened it up, the frame was cracked and damaged. I called customer service, they told me to take pictures, send them and return the item. I did that very day. Fast forward to today, Nov 1. After not receiving a replacement, several phone calls and emails, zero help from them, being told to contact Fedex I was told that Fedex lost the package and there are no more left so I will have to accept a refund in another 7 TO 10 DAYS! If they would have helped me when I started asking for help, maybe they wouldn't be "sold out" of the jersey I bought. No offers to help me find a replacement jersey to make up for their mistakes, no customer service, just sorry, we'll have to give you a refund.

Tip for consumers:
Use a different site

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user lisab691
West Virginia
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 8th, 2018

I ordered an autographed picture as a surprise for a birthday gift. As the birthday approached I became concerned because the gift had not arrived. I contacted customer service and Shelby Coyle found out what was going on and kept me informed. She was extremely helpful and concerned that I got the surprise gift on time. Thanks to her I did get the gift on time and it was a big surprise. Thanks.

Thumbnail of user priscillap10
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 22nd, 2017

I wanted to give a BIG thank you to Donna O'Donnell for being amazing with my purchase and with the tracking. I don't think I've been helped before with this great customer service... I for sure will be buying more in the future... Thanks Donna for helping out with my two purchases...

Thumbnail of user dianai18
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 13th, 2018

I was very impressed by the prompt helpfulness of Shelby Coyle in resolving the issue I had with the gift card I ordered for someone. The gift card was received in a timely manner after I contacted her about a problem in receiving it. Again, thanks for your prompt help!

Thumbnail of user lizg49
New Hampshire
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 2nd, 2018

Connie handled my questions in a timely manner. She communicated me on 3 different occasions to make sure that I understood the changes in my order and to report that the item had been shipped according to my request. I appreciated her polite and friendly phone demeanor.

Thumbnail of user brianb1553
Colorado
2 reviews
6 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 3rd, 2022

I bought a photo with a signature from the site that said it had a lifetime authenticity guarantee. When I received the photo, it came with a card that said to check the serial number and affixed tamper-resistant hologram. The photo has neither a serial number nor a hologram. I reached out to the company to point out the problem. They initially responded quickly and asked me to send them photographs of the front and back of the photo. I sent them pictures within 5 minutes of their request. It has now been 2 days, and the company has not responded to 2 follow-up emails. I'm afraid I may end up having to take this up with my bank, and consumer affairs.

Edit: 5 emails later and I still have not received a response from the company.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user pauls1070
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 12th, 2019

Shelby Coyle helped me and did a great job! The site never sent me a confirmation email after I purchased the item. I chatted online with Shelby and she helped me greatly. Everything was square and no issues.

Thumbnail of user melissat162
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 12th, 2018

Gabriel Miranda provided excellent customer service. After having received a replicated signed item from another provider, I found Sports Memorabilia and purchased a new item for my fiance for Christmas. Given the short notice, I was told the item wouldn't be shipped until Dec 21 which was cutting it close to Christmas. Gabriel immediately ensured that the item shipped earlier and made sure to keep in touch with me to provide updates. I received the item in less than a week and couldn't be happier.

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Buy sports memorabilia, autographs & signed gifts from MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL. Find baseball, football, basketball, hockey autographed jerseys.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user erinf11
Nigel P.
Marketing Specialist
Typically responds within 12 days

How do I know I can trust these reviews about SportsMemorabilia.com?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about SportsMemorabilia.com?