Moon Magic has a rating of 4.2 stars from 653 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Moon Magic most frequently mention customer service, high quality and many compliments. Moon Magic ranks 8th among Custom Jewelry sites.
Taking the time to write a review for this horrible company as they will delete anything negative on their social media that they can.
Ordered my Wife a Moonstone Ring for Christmas on November 27th. It didn't arrive until Christmas eve and wasn't even shipped out for almost 3 weeks after ordering it.
When it arrived, it looked nothing like the natural stones in the photos. Just a square rock that looked like garbage. As other have mentioned, their sizing is completely off and the ring fit way too big on my wife.
The worst part? Trying to return an item is a nightmare. Their customer service is garbage, it took them 2 weeks to answer my e-mail and their answer is that I have to pay for return shipping to Florida from Toronto if I want a new size or to return an item. Are you kidding me? You're an online retailer, you forgo the cost of a brick and mortar store knowing full well people will need to try your items on to make sure they fit. This place is a total joke - I am going out of my way to return this item and to tell people not to deal with this company.
They use social media and a BOATLOAD of fake reviews to make their products seem like they're anything special. I absolutely cannot recommend enough that you stay away from these people. Garbage products, garbage service, one of the worst online retailers I have ever had to deal with. Buyer beware - don't flush your money down the toilet with this company.
They have amazing customer service and fantastic jewelry! No two pieces are alike! They are prompt, helpful and eager to solve your issue if you have one! Definitely recommend!
Hello Amy,
We're very glad to hear that you had a positive experience with our company and that you love our jewelry! Thank you very much for your recommendation.
All the best,
Moon Magic
I returned the two rings I bought and they claimed they only received one so withheld $55. I researched them online and found they have done this to other customers. Don't buy anything from them!
Hello Amy,
Thank you very much for sharing your experience. We are sorry but we can only confirm what arrived at our warehouse. These cases are very rare, and very often customers find the other item at their home. We are very sorry about your experience and for any inconvenience.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Was not high quality as it appeared in the pictures Received on Friday requested return on Sat - they want to only give me 60% refund- Also dont order the wrapping.
Hello Christine,
We are truly sorry to hear that you are not happy with your purchase!
Please note that the 60% refund is one of the options in case you would like to keep the items you have purchased. You are free to return them for a full refund of the purchase price. Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I am very pleased with the service and the care shown by the employees in shaping the order, which always arrives on time, safe and sound. Thank you all very much!
Hello Dwain,
Thank you so much for your kind words. This really means a lot! You are a valued customer and your satisfaction is very important to us!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I'm still doubtful of Instagram ads. Some companies I buy from are legitimate. This one is a mixed bag which I've never experienced before. For one thing, the gems are way more appealing looking on the website. I ordered a moonstone ring and it's still a nice ring, but for the price I paid, I wasn't expecting a boring, cloudy looking stone.
The shipping was weird too. This was during Cyber Monday and I did my shopping from different companies, yet this was the only order where they didn't ship it until 6 whole days after I ordered it. All my other orders where shipped 1-2 days after I ordered. The only excuse I'll accept is they were overwhelmed by the sale.
The most puzzling part is that they claim to be based in Florida. In fact, I live about 2 hours away from where they shipped my ring from, so you can understand my confusion when my bank account showed not just what my ring cost, but there was a Foreign transaction fee that was a measly $. 075. The location is from Germany and there's nothing on the site that mentions that at all. Why is there money going to Germany when I ordered from a "Floridian" company? It left me a little uneasy because as I stated before, I live practically 2 hours away from where they shipped my order from, why am I getting a Foreign transaction fee and why is it not mentioned anywhere on their site?
So basically, their products are way too overpriced for dull looking stones that don't match how shiny and pretty they are on the site and they don't tell you about a foreign fee even though this is supposed to be a company that ships from the US.
Hello Moyar,
Thank you for your review, we truly appreciate it. We really hope we can make your experience better.
That would be a transaction fee charged by your credit card institute or the issuer of the card you used for the purchase. Unfortunately, that is out of our hands. For further information about this, please contact your bank. They will be able to help and explain this fee in more detail. We ship from our warehouse in Florida but the company has international accounts in Germany.
We are very sorry, we had a slight delay due to the number of orders over the Black Friday/Cyber Monday deal days and our warehouse is working around the clock to ship every single item as soon as possible.
If you are not happy with the stone you received you are more then welcome to contact us to sort this out.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
The rings I ordered are beautiful & made perfectly.
I am very happy. The packaging they came in was very professional & I was also able to track my order every step of the way.
Hello Robyn,
Thank you so much for your positive feedback!
We are pleased that you like your Moon Magic rings, please enjoy!
Best regards,
Moon Magic
We purchased a diamond opal ring from Moon Magic and we loved how beautiful the stones and the ring are. Customer service is super reactive and I received excellent communications and services.
Never wore the ring, NOT ONCE & it's tarnished, also missing a "crystal". I order the….
Moonstone Ring - Queenly & Ring - Sovereign Band & Ring - Twinkling Band
(I didn't wear the ring because I got engaged right before it came in the mail, go figure)
Hello there,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are sincerely sorry you are not satisfied with your experience.
Although rare, Silver pieces can tarnish over time due to the precious, natural metals present in their composition, such as Copper. Please find more information https://moonmagic.com/blogs/news/tarnished-jewelry.
If your piece does leave a surface mark on your skin, it can easily be washed off with warm water and soap, while any blackening of the piece can be quickly removed with the polishing cloth that we sent with our deliveries.
Please feel free to reconnect with our customer support for any questions you might have.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
The silver of these products goes a copper colour and they don't allow refunds after 1 month. Also the stones aren't as bright as the pictures suggest.
Hello Harriet,
We are very sorry to hear about your experience. If you received the defective ring you were welcome to contact us within 30 days of delivery and we can exchange it or proceed with the refund. After that period we are coming up with the special offer, we are sorry you didn't find that offer helpful. Again, we are very sorry for any inconvenience.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Not only does the Moon magic store offer beautiful jewelry, but the way the support team treats the clients is amazing. Another reason to love the store.
Hello Lola,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I was dumb enough to purchase 2 rings from moon magic and not looking them up beforehand. It has now been a month since I purchased from them and I still have not received my order. I had been tracking my order since they sent me the tracking email. It never had any updated information on tracking it never changed and one day it said the tracking number said it no longer existed. I'm still going back and forth with moon magic trying to get a refund and they don't want to give it to me. During my month long waiting for the items I looked up reviews and listen to them. The stones fall out after a few days. The jewelry tarnished. The products are cheap. Customer service is a joke. Their "high 3nd jewelry " come in plastic bag rapping!. If it was expensive jewelry they wouldn't put their jewelry in plastic bags!. Listen to all this. Don't do what I did. Take your money and business elsewhere to reputable jewelry companies!. They just took my money and left me high and dry. Listen to me DO NOT PURCHASE FROM MOON MAGIC
Hello Rebecca,
Thank you so much for the 5-stars. We are very happy that you like our services!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
The ring is gorgeous. Only bad thing is I've been wearing it for less than 24 hours and my finger is green. For the price my finger shouldn't be green!
Hello Kayla,
We are very glad to see that you like your ring. I am really sorry to hear your ring has caused a green discoloration, I know how frustrating this can be. However, it is, unfortunately, a common complaint caused by the copper present in all sterling silver jewelry. This can be especially common in hot, humid climates as moisture in the air or skin can make the copper react in this way. I recommend using a silver cloth to regularly polish your ring as this will really help.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Excellent company, beautiful products, and great customer service. The products are great quality and beautiful. Will continue to use this company in the future and refer them to friends!
Hello Nicole,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I was so excited to get my jewelry that my fiancé got me for my birthday. Within two weeks, the rose gold was rubbed off. For the price point, I would have expected maybe a bit more time before that.
Hello Michelle,
We are very sorry to hear about your experience and that you received a defective ring. If you contact our support you will be able to receive a free replacement or full refund. We are very sorry for any inconvenience.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Moon Magic were amazing in fixing my order that was a little too big (not their fault). The jewelry is beautiful, great quality. I will definitely be buying more.
Hello Dina,
Many thanks for your positive feedback - it really means a lot to us!
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Had to return the ring 3 times (first time was my fault, wrong size) and each time we exhanged, it was extremely easy and hassle free. The jewelry is amazing and I would highly recommend it!
Hello Josh,
Thank you so much for this great 5-star review. We really appreciate you being a loyal customer and helping to share the word about us. We’re here for you anytime.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Would just like to say that I cannot recommend this company enough. I purchased an item on Friday 12th of March and it arrived in the UK to my home address on Monday 15th March although I had an issue when the item had arrived I emailed the company and within less than 24 hours it was all resolved and Inna has been absolutely amazing very caring and fantastic customer service, this has inspired me even more to use Moon Magic for the rest of my purchases, I cannot thank you enough for your kindness shown and compassion in a world that is currently dis regulated.
Hello Hannah,
Thank you for your wonderful comment and positive feedback, you just made our day!
Kind Regards,
Moon Magic
I have ordered from this company two or three times now. Some items I've received have been pretty and just like (if not better) than the photo. However, some items I've received are not even slightly like the photo and the stone is way smaller than advertised. I ordered the raw moonstone ring in silver and really liked it (the shape wasn't as pretty as on the site/instagram but I was all right with that). The blue shift was really cool at different angles and lighting. I then ordered the same ring in rose gold and the one that came was not at all the same quality. The stone size was half the size of my silver one and the blue shift/vibrancy was nonexistent. Because they offer a petite version of the ring for much cheaper, I was frustrated I didn't receive the same size and qualify that I did before. The response of stones are unique and will all look different doesn't satisfy my frustration because they have control over the size of the stone (especially since they now offer multiple sizes for different prices).
Hello Ashley,
Many thanks for your feedback. We are very sad that you are not happy with the size of the raw crystal ring you received. However, if you are not satisfied with the ring you can return it for an exchange or for a full refund. The Petite Raw version is different from the regular Raw Crystal ring as you know and no two rings look the same thanks to its natural gemstone beauty and unusual, untreated shape. We hope you understand.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Mi hija me sorprendió con un anillo auténtico de piedra lunar, ¡y no puedo estar más feliz! La piedra tiene un brillo hipnotizante, como si llevara un pedacito de luna en mi mano. La calidad del anillo es excelente; Además, me encanta cómo cambia de tonalidad con la luz, dándole un toque mágico y único. Añado fotos para q lo veais. 100% recommendable.
Hello Dolores,
Thank you for your lovely review! We’re thrilled to hear you’re so happy with your Moonstone ring. Its magical qualities truly make it special.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Answer: ITS 100% scam
Answer: Yes, the main stone in my ring fell out after four months and the company is refusing to refund me. It's only four months old. They say it's only got a one month warranty! A month?! They only have a month warranty because they expect them to break and don't want to give you your money back. Disgusting.
Answer: On their website they had really good reviews! I should have done a little more research!
Answer: Nope, don't have one. I have a few horror stories though.
Answer: I can pay from Germany (Europe) without problems.
Answer: My necklace broke with in a week. It's all smoke show and fake reviews on their website
Answer: Hello Abby, Our jewelry is made from a range of precious metals, including the following: 925 Sterling Silver, Solid Yellow, and Rose Gold and 14k Vermeil which is 925 Sterling Silver plated in 14k Rose and Yellow Gold (this coating is 50% thicker than traditional gold-plated pieces, keeping it beautiful for years to come). All the best, Moon Magic
Hello Luke,
We are very sorry to hear about your unhappy experience with us. Due to the drastic increase in sales volume our fulfillment center had synchronization issues. Please accept our apologies for the delays regarding the shipping of your order.
We are very sorry that you didn't like the ring. When it comes to our raw rings, please note that no two rings look the same thanks to its natural gemstone beauty and unusual, untreated shape.
As per our Return Policy, you are responsible to pay the return shipping if the item is not defective. However, we will cover the shipping fee on sending a new item back out to you if you would like it.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic