• Personalization Mall

Personalization Mall

Write a Review

Overview

Personalization Mall has a rating of 2.1 stars from 525 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Personalization Mall most frequently mention customer service, tracking number, and christmas gifts problems. Personalization Mall ranks 165th among Promotional Products sites.

  • Service
    141
  • Value
    137
  • Shipping
    142
  • Returns
    86
  • Quality
    124

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 52.9%
Positive
9
Neutral
0
Negative
8
145
See all photos
How would you rate Personalization Mall?
Top Positive Review

“Banners!”

Pamela M.
6/30/24

Loved the Birthday banners for my mom's 85th birthday. I received it so fast I could believe it. Waay better than Amazon and the clarity is awesome

Top Critical Review

“WORST COSTUMER SERVICE!”

Giovanna P.
6/19/24

Bought an item & paid $25 2day rush delivery. Never got it due to FedEx mistake. PMall didn't assume any responsibility & on top of that pretended to keep charging me the rush delivery since they were going to re-send it the same way. I asked to be charged only the 4day express delivery because it was going to be 5 days later (which was fair) but staff member Patricia in a VERY condescending disrespectful way refused to do it saying she couldn't understand where I was coming from asking for the partial refund - acting as I, after going thru this ordeal and not getting what I had paid for, was trying to take advantage of them? Of course I opted for full refund, no item for my special occasion and no chance on getting anything else on time. Regret choosing them for this event. DO NOT RISK IT if is something important!

Reviews (525)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

personalization mall (68) customer service (216) delivery date (13)
Thumbnail of user johnw6978
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 25th, 2023

Thursday before Mother's Day ordered a "World's Best Mom" cap for my lovely wife. It was personalized with her nickname on the back of the cap. Paid an extra 27.00+ for Guaranteed Saturday delivery (to get it before Mother's Day).

Received the hat on Monday (sorry Mom), with no personalized embroidery.

I'd like an embroidered hat for Mom and my money back!

Tip for consumers:
VERY DISSAPPOINTED

Products used:
none

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user joer245
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 7th, 2017

I am rewriting an earlier review of PersonalizationMall because a customer service representative (Patricia) read my negative review, contacted me, and made it right by by sending me a new custom engraved wood ornament that originally arrived defective. Whatever negative opinion I originally formed about their satisfaction guarantee was more than made up by the effort that was made to rectify my issue- I especially appreciated the Fedex Next Day Delivery that delivered my keepsake ornament in time for Christmas. The replaced ornament was craftily made and arrived as described. I will definitely do business with them going forward.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

We apologize for the inconsistencies Joe, Can you please send us your order number so we can look into this and make it right?

Thumbnail of user rosem859
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 16th, 2021

Reading the reviews, I was a bit nervous about ordering an ornament for my grandsons first Christmas, but they had exactly what I want. I am very happy with the ornament, it came the exact day they said it would. And the ornament is awesome. I would have like the writing to be a bit bigger, but that's not their fault. Very impressed and I will definitely order from this company again

Tip for consumers:
Nothing

Products used:
Christmas ornament

Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Thanks for the review Rose! We are happy to have impressed you and look forward to impressing you with future orders.

Thumbnail of user tracyb659
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 18th, 2020

My order that I placed on 11/29 that was supposedly shipped on 12/02 has been sitting in Atlanta since December 10... label created for usps but it's not moved from The place in Atlanta. I ordered this somewhat early to get it before Christmas. I get that there are shipping delays, but it's absolutely ridiculous that it hasn't made any progress. And, your company has the nerve to send emails and advertise that there is still time to order and get items before Christmas. What a joke. If I do not receive it ASAP, I will dispute the charges with my my bank. I see from all the horrible reviews of this same thing happening that I made a huge mistake ordering from you.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hey, Tracy. We apologize for the delays to your order, and wish to help escalate your concerns to our customer service management team. Could you please provide your order number via the private message we just sent you so that we can assist?

Thumbnail of user ericah212
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 20th, 2020

I purchased a custom photo bath mat from their website for a Christmas gift. When the bath mat arrived, it was faintly duplicated and smeared over the black caption box in the upper right hand corner. I sent an email with photos included to Personalization Mall asking them to reprint the mat due to the error. They got back to me and said that the quality was inspected and the mat was made according to the design and they would not be reprinting it. The design is not duplicated at all. The printing was their mistake. They offered me a 20% discount off of my next order. I would never purchase anything from them again. I've filed a complaint with the BBB and a PayPal dispute.

Thumbnail of user twilam2
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
October 14th, 2017

I ordered a Christmas gift for my father and it totally was not what I expected. I called customer service and was told very bluntly by a rep that there were no returns on personalized items. I am very displeased and disappointed not only with the item but with the so called customer service. All Calls Should Be Recorded! I will be telling my IG followers, Facebook, Family and Friends to never order anything for this company.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Dear Twila,
We apologize that you were not happy with your order. We have send you a private message asking for your order number so we can look into this issue. Please reply to our message with your order number so we can make this right. Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Thumbnail of user billg64
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
May 14th, 2017

The order came to $65 and wasn't even nothing like the picture online. My glass clock with a poem on it was so small, it's crazy. Also the "guaranteed Mother's Day delivery" is bs. My item came 2 days after please do not waste your money, nor bother trying.

Thumbnail of user gk142
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 15th, 2022

Tried to call 3 days in a row; on hold for 1hr. 45 minutes so far today; 60 minutes yesterday. Never an answer or call back. My question doesn't fit into their limited email categories and no room to ask anything else. I used to love this place.

Thumbnail of user fg27
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 3rd, 2018

This company has terrible customer service they dont trust there customers...
Order a keychain and it never arrived when i contacted them they say check by neighbors then the open investigation for 20 bucks

Thumbnail of user jenniferb2063
2 reviews
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 19th, 2020

Placed my order on December 2nd. December 5th got notice that USPS was awaiting the item from PM, which they have yet to receive. I've emailed them several times, sent FB messages, tried Twitter and called. No one has gotten back with me. At this point I've given up that these items will ever come. What a let down.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hey, Jennifer. We are very sorry to hear about the delay in delivery and response to your multiple inquires. Can you please provide your order number via private message so that we can help you further?

Thumbnail of user jakes110
1 review
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 9th, 2018

Stay clear of these guys. I ordered a customized blanket from their website. When I entered my shipping address it estimated delivery in 8-10 business days for $17.99. I thought this was a bit pricy but paid anyway because I live in Hawaii. Over 3 weeks later my order has still not arrived! The special occasion was missed. Personalization Mall has refused to issue a refund on any portion.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

We apologize your personalized gift didn't arrive in time Jake. Please reply to our private message with your order number so we can try to make this right. Thank you!

Thumbnail of user laurah1300
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 17th, 2020

Ordered a bathrobe in November as a Christmas present still have not received it but they took my money. No response either from them. I will be reaching out to my lawyer and that states attorney generals office as well as the better business, so no one else gets taken advantage.
*******@yahoo.com

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Laura. Thank you for reaching out, and we are so sorry that your order has been delayed. If you would be so kind as to provide your order number via the private message we just sent you, I can help escalate your concerns to our customer service management team for immediate review.

Thumbnail of user janaer1
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 24th, 2017

I ordered from them the day before Christmas. I found some unique ideas for great prices. Needless to say, I never received the gift I was going to give. Upon contacting them I asked for my money back. They responded by saying they would send me another one. Never arrived. Contacted them again and they refused to give me money back AND a tracking number. They know what their doing when it comes to stealing and fraud. Bad.

Thumbnail of user taniar115
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
May 31st, 2022

I saw that they offered exedited shipping so I ordered a customized banner for my daughter's graduation party. I paid for next day shipping and the item didn't arrive until 5 days later. They would only refund my shipping. I wouldn't recommend this site. Go to local walmart photo center instead. Email said it'd be in on Friday. Just arrived today (Tues).

Tip for consumers:
Go to local walmart photo center instead

Products used:
Yard banner

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user susanm2426
2 reviews
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 8th, 2020

I bought my grandson a personalized baseball bat 4 months ago. It didn't reach him before his birthday due to some PO address problem so it came back to personalization mall. They were supposed to charge me another 5.95 to ship, but charged me for the bat all over again along with shipping charges! I will never do business with them again snd I have 23 grandchildren. Don't patronize them unless you you want to be ripped off!

Tip for consumers:
That I would have to rebuy the bat!

Products used:
Baseball bat

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Susan. This is definitely not the type of experience we want to provide, and are so sorry for the confusion. If you could please respond to the private message we sent with your order number, we would like to investigate further to help correct any issues.

Thumbnail of user annm154
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 28th, 2016

Their website is very difficult once you get to the payment screen. Cart went empty, never stated order was completed. Placed order again then saw two emails confirming order. I tried to reach them immediately and they were closed. Sent email immediately. Called the next morning the minute they opened and they refused to cancel the duplicate order. I asked them very nicely to do the right thing and she kept insisting that they would not cancel the duplicate order. I have called my credit card company and they will charge it back to them.

Thumbnail of user kevinj567
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
November 23rd, 2020

After waiting 3 weeks and another week of there company telling me it was still in transit. They finally decided to act. This was with opening an investigation for 5 days. Then remaking it and remailing it. Did not offer any upgraded mail so overall it took about 2 months to receive.

Thumbnail of user coreyh149
1 review
4 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 18th, 2020

I ordered my wife a Christmas present on 11/27/20 and was told it shipped on 11/30. Last update was 12/4/20 sayi g ot was in the way to the shipper. No updates at all since then. I have tried to call them everyday for the past week and they keep saying call volumes are high and to try back later. I'm guessing they are so busy because no one is getting their packages! I also tried e-mailing with no response! What a joke of a company! Never doing business with them again... who knows how I will get my money back!

Order #*******

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Corey. We are so sorry for the delays to your order, and for the longer than usual response times to your inquires. It looks like we were able to successfully process a remake of your order this morning 12/18 on an expedited production track. We hope this helps alleviates your concerns for now, but if there's anything else we can do in the meantime to make your experience better, please let us know.

Thumbnail of user rw473
3 reviews
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 11th, 2020

I am updating my initial review. I was initially frustrated, but once the company became aware of the problem, the responded and promptly sent my order to me. I really like this company because they have very nice products. They indicated they will be making corrections with their shipping, which will fix the problems. I have always been happy with my orders and now that the problem is solved, I will definitely continue to order from them.

Tip for consumers:
Their products are very nice. I like ordering from them. I was frustrated recently because I had not received my order and was unable to contact anyone, but once they became aware of the problem they responded and shipped my order to me right away. The problem was resolved, and I will continue to shop with them. I like their products.

Products used:
Personalized gifts - blankets, sympathy items, items for children, masks, ornaments, and more. Each item met my expectations, and everyone I purchased them for really liked them.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, R. W. We are deeply sorry for the delivery delays for your order, and want to make this right. Please reply back to our private message with your order number and we will do everything we can to get your order delivered. Thanks again for being a loyal PMall customer.

Thumbnail of user stephaniep641
1 review
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 19th, 2020

Purchased gifts for Christmas on December 6th. Received an update telling me the package was shipped. The ONLY other update I received was that the package has been sitting in York PA since December 12th- a full week ago. Finally spoke with someone on the phone who basically said "oh well, there are delays". Really? It takes more than 3 weeks to order gifts for Christmas? Run screaming. Use Etsy. Those folks give a $#*!.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Stephanie. We are very sorry to hear about the delivery delays to your order, and would love to help investigate further. Can you please reply back to the private message we sent you with your order number so that we can do so?

Thumbnail of user deborahj1206
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 31st, 2022

I recently lost my dog after 15 years of nothing but love and happiness. I placed an order for a pillow and blanket in her memory. I got shortly afterwards and loved it! I will order again and I highly recommend them

Products used:
Pillow and blanket

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user janiceb1341
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
December 15th, 2023

Had ornaments made for my grandkids and you can't read the personalization on them. You think they would call and explain to you about the print. My grandsons are not taking the passing of their grandfather well and I only would like to have them replaced and they wouldn't do it. That's why they only have a 1.9 rating.

Tip for consumers:
Not customer friendly

Products used:
Non. Have to see if I could cover up the personalization

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user anchc
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 15th, 2017

I cannot remember ever being so disgusted by an online shopping experience! I ordered a personalized coffee mug and plaque for my husband for Valentines Day and this company managed to get the entire order wrong and then proceeded to say it was my fault and they would not replace the items as if I don't know my wedding date! These people need to be reported to the BBB. Not only did they not care that they ruined my husbands gift, but to turn around and blame the customer for your own ineptitude is inexcusable! Do not buy from these people! Signed, angry and disappointed wife.

Thumbnail of user michelles1749
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 16th, 2020

I ordered from this company before Thanksgiving. They sent a email stating that the item had been shipped but it hasn't moved since November 23. USPS still hasn't received it. I have reached out to this company 2 times now and get the same message. Since I chose economy shipping it will take 5 to 10 business days. It's been well over that. They are also using Covid as a excuse. So now I am beginning to wonder if I will ever receive it. Its a Christmas gift for my mom. Poor customer service. Don't promise something and not follow thru. I guess I am out of $65.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Michelle. We apologize on behalf of our carrier partner that your order is taking longer than expected to arrive. If you would be so kind as to provide your order number in response to the private message we just sent, we will escalate your concerns to our customer service management team immediately for further review.

Thumbnail of user gwenr3
17 reviews
74 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 30th, 2015

I've ordered personalized mugs, cups and golf balls, they all turned out amazing, loved them and they made great gifts. Sometimes I was not able to find what I was looking for online so its nice to be able to design your own gifts for friends and family. We ordered wedding labels, they turned out perfect, exactly what we wanted and could not find anywhere else. I've ordered cards for weddings & anniversaries and they all turned out great, were a reasonable price, even with shipping they were still on par with store prices... and they we personalized to each person or couple which made them more special than store bought.

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Gift giving made easy! Shop thousands of unique, personalized gifts for men, women & kids - for every occasion. Always free personalization & fast shipping.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Personalization Mall?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Personalization Mall?