The usher took us to the ticket box who confirmed our tickets were original however, the original ticket holder can report them loss or stolen and reprint them online which is exactly what they did. The people who were sitting in our seats were printed

I do not. They wouldn't sell me the tickets unless I gave them more info. I did buy the exact set of tickets with NO drama. My AmEx card experienced fraudulent activity the next day. Multiple fraudulent attempts with 48 hours of trying to use the seat geek website. First time my card was compromised since 1990.