Review of Thumbtack: Thumbtack Generates FAKE Accounts to Send FALSE Leads; Will Not Refund
Thumbnail of user km435
New Jersey
4 reviews
24 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 14th, 2023

Thumbtack generates numerous accounts to send false leads (potential customers) to the "pros." With each generated account, they send one "lead" to five pros. Each pro is charged $30 or more for each "lead," which I have experienced and observed, multiple times, every day I was a member of the platform. Shameful, deceptive and unethical practices. Customer service is poor, nearly non-existent. And, don't expect any refunds...you won't get any.

Service
Value
Quality

Date of experience: July 14, 2023

Share Review on:

  • Bookmark

    Thumbtack

Thumbtack

Write a Review

Overview

Thumbtack has a rating of 1.6 stars from 1,566 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Thumbtack most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and phone number problems. Thumbtack ranks 99th among Local Reviews sites.

  • Service
    293
  • Value
    285
  • Shipping
    118
  • Returns
    163
  • Quality
    255

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 2.4%
Positive
1
Neutral
1
Negative
39
View ratings trends
How would you rate Thumbtack?
Top Positive Review

“Totally cleaned up my Yard~.”

Cynthia H.
3/13/24

Cut the grass, pulled weeds, finished with mulch all in 30 min! Did a fantastic job! Thank you Roberto Lopez from Lopez Landscaping and tree Services. *******226

Date of experience: 3/13/24
See positive reviews
Top Critical Review

“100% scam”

Barry G.
12/1/24

Don't bother working with them! They are useless and using bots and not qualified leads that request a job and want to pay 50 bucks while some projects are minimum $500-750. No customer service total bs and you will lose loads of money on "leads" as they call them but it's just fake accounts that show some sort of activity.

Date of experience: 12/1/24
See critical reviews

Reviews (1,566)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (157) phone number (58) credit card (53) business model (30) home advisor (23)
Thumbnail of user amyc607
Virginia
1 review
6 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 4th, 2019

Thumbtack is a waste of money and a rip off. This is coming from someone who used Thumbtack for almost 5 years before deciding to walk away. They charge a pro like myself (I am a DJ) between $15-50 per "lead" when you sign up for their Instant Match service. Most of these "leads" don't respond at all, let alone hire you, but you still get charged for being matched with them. All it leads to is small business owners throwing hundreds of dollars away each week for zero results. Logically, this would lead to small business owners raising their prices - but don't do that, because Thumbtack has no shortage of vendors who low ball the market. $200 to DJ your 6 hour wedding? Sure, no problem! Stuff like that.

Oh, and if you choose not to sign up for Instant Matching? You won't get jobs in yoru area - they will only send you jobs that are 100-150 miles away.

Bottom line: this company got way, way too greedy and started gauging small businesses. Now, it's basically impossible for small businesses to afford their services (not that they care). DO NOT USE THEM.

Date of experience: October 4, 2019

Thumbnail of user lenac11
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 12th, 2016

Diana Kaeding teaches Voice Lessons in Bradenton FL and I have been going for a couple of months now and will continue. I wasn't sure I could sing at all (just a beginner) when I first began lessons, but Diana has really helped me tremendously. I recommend her highly!

Date of experience: July 11, 2016

Thumbnail of user johne474
California
1 review
9 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 10th, 2019

This used to be a great company, building up their business by having a functional online platform, fair prices and good treatment of professionals, very unusual in their industry and obviously a huge breath of fresh air! After they grew, they very gradually became greedy and corrupt. It is one shady move after another in pursuit of freeloading money from professionals. Prices for their services have increased about 5 times in the last year or so, I don't think we have had even 10% of that of inflation in our ballooning economy. Their latest scam, they change your travel service preferences without your permission so you get many irrelevant and unwanted emails. When you go back in to change everything to your own original preferences, they try to force you to do some promotion thing and essentially get on a auto-subscription set up even if you don't want to. They are going straight down the toilet and I have stopped using them for a while now already. There is no nice way to say it when a company tries to take advantage of its customers in these ways: Greedy, worthless and doomed!

Date of experience: April 10, 2019

Thumbnail of user daniels372
Massachusetts
1 review
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 3rd, 2018

I am precision paint and design in Massachusetts and a Sherwin Williams contractor of 30yrs with non stop consistent 5 star reviews... 2 months ago I notice the agreement I had with thumbtack and a 4 contractor bidding system was fine... now 6 contractors are paying for as low as a 1 bedroom lead for painting,,, 6? You kidding me? After 30yrs and my stats show people stop answering calls from contractors on these sites after 2-4 tops. No one speaks to 6... thumbtack has claimed customers want more contractors and blame them. However this is a straight lie on national stats in marketing for contractors across the board... my 5 star rating when I bid, and then appear for an appointment am usually the stopping point for customers. In other words if they have a couple more estimates set? Normally they say we want you and will cancel those appointments... so the customer is normally satisfied with us so 6 need not be in my universe of leads... none of these want 6 or most even 4 contractors calling or emailing, they get sick of it fast. Anyway I guess and know you don't care about me or any contractors and but for warning other contractors this review is futile to change a thing in the greed of selling the same lead multiple times... another home advisors and worse on 6,, they don't even go that far.

Date of experience: January 3, 2018

Thumbnail of user jewelb11
Georgia
2 reviews
7 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 7th, 2016

I used thumbtack to find a landscaper. Dunn 2 perfection was good the first year. However at some point, their bookkeeping and communication turned very bad. I sent many emails that informed them they were wrong about me being behind on payment. They would agree and apologize. This happened at least 3 separate times. It got to the point I had to take snapshots of cleared checks and send it to them. Just this June, they abruptly stopped coming to cut our grass. My husband called and he was told they mistakenly thought we were behind. The woman called us back to say they would be out there that day or the next day. It took 3 days for them to show up and we received no call or email explaining why. The day after they cut the grass, I got another invoice saying I had a past due amount. What?! This was just addressed a few days ago on the phone. I promptly emailed and asked which month was in question because I was ready for a response. I had already pulled out all my checkbooks and went online again to take screenshots. I got no response. I sent that email over July 1st (7 days ago). I will send payment for one month of service and be done. Maybe I'll get a reply when they see the check is less than the invoice. That's all I ever wanted--a reply. Poor communication and questionable billing.

Date of experience: July 7, 2016

Thumbnail of user karenb337
Colorado
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 16th, 2017

Won't be using thumbtack again. Had a patio poured with cover only to find out after the fact that the contractor isn't licensed. Used cheap material and wouldn't use again.

Date of experience: October 16, 2017

Thumbnail of user markh4333
Texas
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 25th, 2023

They told me I could join and get leads I paid $200 I didn't get anything I tried to cancel nobody would have call me back in the time frame 10 days. I did not get one single lead in 1 month the guy that I joined from told me I was going to get leads his name is Chris this is the worst legioneration platform I've ever used in my life

Date of experience: February 25, 2023

Thumbnail of user malindav5
South Dakota
3 reviews
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
August 18th, 2021

I wish there was zero stars as a rating!
This is a scam! I hired a handyman to put locks on two doors. He showed up 2 hours late because his wife made him breakfast? Then when he got to our home he did not have the right tools to install the dead bolts so took another hour away to go to the hardware for tools? A job that should have started at 9am for an hour on a Sunday took all day!
Then I tried thumbtack again for pressure washing our home. I received a text response from a contractor at 12:16 a.m. which I did not see till the next morning. He told me I costed him to loose $11.00 and not to waste his time? I had no idea what he was talking about... he later texted me that he was made that I requested multiple bids for the work and flipped me off with a emoji! Who does this?
I requested quotes on lawn mowing and without even looking at our yard in person was quoted $ 80, $50, $40, but none of these people could outline what they would do for these dollar amounts? The area to mow is under 600 ft. The $50 quote was from a contractor who advertises under 1000 ft. Mowing, trimming. Edging and weed eating for $25? Then I call thumbtack to make them aware and the guy who answered my call took my complaint as a personal attack and hung up on me. Their calls are recorded but when I called back to speak to management, I was left on hold for 25 minutes, so hung up and wrote this. Thumbtack can't be legit. Ever contractor I have had any contact with has been as flake trying to get your credit card number on text messages? Who does this?

Tip for consumers:
Call hardware stores, big box hardwares for their reference lists of legit contracts for all jobs around the house !

Products used:
I only used a handyman service. Could not get a straight answer from any of the other contracts regarding the price or scope of work to be done!

Service
Value
Quality

Date of experience: August 18, 2021

Thumbnail of user thumbtackt
Thumbtack-Support -. – Thumbtack Rep

Hi Malinda, thank you for providing us with this feedback. This isn't the experience we want customers to have, thank you for giving us the opportunity to address your concerns and improve. We have high standards for pros on the platform and the details you shared about your interactions are definitely concerning. Please report these concerns here, to our Trust and Safety Team: https://help.thumbtack.com/report-a-concern. We'll review the details you share and our team will follow up with you. We're sorry to hear about the experience you had with our support team, but we'll be sure to reach out to you after you submit your case. We hope that we can help you move forward and once more appreciate your review.

Thumbnail of user juanb466
California
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
February 13th, 2023

I put my limit at 40 bucks for leads, and over night they took 200 bucks! For customer service all they got is a damn robot text. If you want too get robbed theyre the best

Tip for consumers:
If you dont like having money,and like being robbed go too them

Products used:
Thumbtack pro

Service
Value
Quality

Date of experience: February 13, 2023

Thumbnail of user katrinak97
Maryland
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 11th, 2021

AFTER THEY TAKE YOUR CREDIT CARD FORGET IT. AFTER MULTIPLE TIMES OF TRYING TO CONTACT THUMBTACK NO ONE EVER GETS BACK TO YOU AND THEY SAND LEADS THAT ARE NOT EVEN IN THE CATAGORY OR WORK I DO OR SIGNED UP FOR

Date of experience: April 11, 2021

Thumbnail of user johnm1182
Kentucky
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 8th, 2017

Right for people crappy for contractors they charge $300 deposit plus they charge you to bid plus they want a percentage of the job by the time it's all done I have to charge the customer eight times what I usually charge than if they just called me on my cell phone for a job because I have to pay them to get it it's not worth it and if you don't get the job you still have to pay them I hope they go under and never open another page it's not worth my time

Date of experience: October 8, 2017

Thumbnail of user dominickd22
Maryland
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 20th, 2020

Thumbtack was great at first it was simple and ro the point with decent quote prices. But like everyone else that has a good thing going I'm sure they dragged in a bunch of empty suits with "fresh ideas " and ran it into the destructive course I'm about to lay out. Basically the old system was pay to quote this job but they charged a little to much so I'm sure they had a lot of refund requests. So instead of charging less and not having to refund everything they literally tripled the prices on what they called "direct quotes" and entrapped you by sending you only requests from hundreds of miles away. This way you would pay for the bull$#*! more expensive requests. Anybody could see the scam there but the best part was when they upgraded my service and started charging my credit card for leads I didn't know I was getting because I stopped using their crooked service regularly. I would like to give them 0 stars I got my money when I complained to my bank because they wouldn't refund me. If any anyone reading this is in a business like thumbtack open the flood gates to succeed and charge no more than 10 dollars for a lead because most are tire kickers and craftsman don't like dumping money into an ocean of online deception

Date of experience: April 20, 2020

Thumbnail of user lindam252
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 2nd, 2016

Hebert from H&M painting was exceptional. Fair price and did more than I asked for. Very clean and professional. I will hire him to do my next painting job.

Date of experience: April 1, 2016

Thumbnail of user stephend550
Illinois
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
July 30th, 2020

Fraudulent charges for leads that do not meet my job description. I was recently charged for 3 separate service requests that were labeled as financial planning, which is the service I provide. I responded to leads that were labeled as such. When the leads contacted me to begin service, they each individually described their needed service to be something other than financial planning, such as tax planning, and business planning, which I do not provide. When contacting Thumbtack about this, they said that since I sought out these jobs in their opportunities section, they are not responsible for the job, and I pay for the lead no matter what. This basically means... if someone advertises for financial planning, and it turns out they need a roof leak fixed, I am responsible for paying for the lead even though it was falsely advertised. The definition of fraud is wrongful or criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain. This definition fits what Thumbtack is practicing in.

Date of experience: July 30, 2020

Thumbnail of user kw537
Arizona
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 11th, 2022

You see Thumbtack reviews by pros, we all dislike them.

I have been in business for more than 25 years, I know my client base. Customers that send requests through thumbtack choose the cheapest quote 9 times out of 10, then you see them complaining about the service. Well you get what you pay for. Only low quality pros bother with Thumbtack because it SUCKS! Leads are expensive, and people are cheap.

Stop whining about getting low quality service if you think the cheapest bid is the best! Thumbtack is too easily manipulated. They will get exactly $0 of my money. I know my customer base very well, and when people talk to me they know i come with experience and credentials. On Thumbtack it doesn't matter. I would love to say I feel sympathy for Thumbtack users, but I really dont. It seems to draw in low quality leads, and a lot of fakes. Why would any smart business owner spend good money after bad?

See the screen shot? Out of 10 leads paid for only 1 person hired for a measley $150 job. 6 of them never even responded, the other 3 just picked the cheapest bid possible. Thats over $200 in leads for a big waste of time.

Thumbtack tried to bring me back onboard with them as I was a top pro with 150 plus 5 star reviews, they were once a great platform but over time it turned to garbage, They gave me $300 in free credit to try. I have to say its even worse than I remember. PRO's, dont waste your time or money!

Tip for consumers:
Avoid!

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality

Date of experience: February 11, 2022

Thumbnail of user thumbtackt
Thumbtack-Support -. – Thumbtack Rep

Thank you for taking the time to share this honest feedback as a business owner. We're sorry to hear that you feel this way about the platform, but we understand it might not work for everyone. To address some of the concerns you mentioned, it's important to us that we provide resources and tools for a variety of business to showcase their experience, expertise, credentials, reviews, and previous work. We also have a team dedicated to helping customers resolve project issues when things don't go as planned. We appreciate all reviews so that we can work to improve and also get in touch with users if they need additional support.

Thumbnail of user mikem465
California
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 21st, 2017

BEWARE my experience with a Thumbtack referral has been a total nightmare. The "professional" they referred cost me $620. In losses commuting multiple illegal actions. He appears to be unstable and possibly dangerous. None of the claims made by their "professionals" in their profiles are verified by Thumbtack. Their definition of a "professional" to Thumbtack is anyone who wil pay their fees, no questions asked. When costumer service reps. Are contacted they have no authority to do anything other than offering patronizing empathy and offer to mediate between victim's and their victimizing "professional". No one will respond to my questions. No one at the company deputies my accusations or attempts to defend their clients obvious indisputable illegal actions. The " professional " stole my money and refuses to reimburse me. Considering their " professional " claimed to be a LLC and a trained mechanical engineer on his Thumbtack profile it was a surprise to learn he lives in a camping trailer at a local county park campground. The California secretary of state has no listing of the claimed LLC in their database. I'm certain this "professional" doesn't have the money to refund and may be violent if angered. I had a reasonable expectation that "hire with confidence" as Thumbtack promotes would be more than promotional empty lies.

Date of experience: January 21, 2017

Thumbnail of user namen6
Washington
1 review
7 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 24th, 2017

My company uses Thumbtack frequently to find handymen for jobs in our area and they've been pretty good up until today. My coworker is typically the one who posts the jobs but last night I posted one and this morning, I realized I inputted the wrong zip code for job location. I updated that information and no more than 5 minutes later I tried to view my account and it said it was disabled. I contacted Thumbtack and this was their response: "we have found links between your account and other accounts that was removed from Thumbtack. Please understand that the decision to remove your account from our platform is final, and cannot be circumvented through the creation of connected accounts." I asked for clarification because I'd never created an account before last night and this was their response: "Since we found links on your account that is not in line with how Thumbtack is intended to be used, and for those reasons we won't be able to reinstate the account. We can't provide any more information due to our privacy policy."

What does that even mean? How can you ban my account but not give any clarification? Such a shame. I'll never recommend them to anyone ever again.

Date of experience: May 24, 2017

Thumbnail of user priscillar156
Georgia
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
January 10th, 2023

IF ANYONE COMES TO THIS SITE, RUN AWAY AND PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU DON'T PAY IN ADVANCE LIKE I DID. PAID IN ADVANCE NEVER SAW THE GUY AGAIN! CONTACTED THUMBTACK TO GET REFUND, GOT THE RUNAROUND - FILLED OUT REFUND REQUEST4 TIMES GOT SILENT TREATMENT. THEY ARE THE WORST EVER! 2022-23. KEEP YOUR MONEY!

Tip for consumers:
DON'T PAY IN ADVANCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Products used:
HANDYMAN - DARON FLEET

Date of experience: January 10, 2023

Thumbnail of user venniel
New Jersey
1 review
11 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 5th, 2018

Thumbtack is garbage... THEY USE TO BE A GOOD PLATFORM Like you all say. Lets put THUMBTACK OUT OF BUSINESS. WE WAS THE PAYING CUSTOMER THAT THEY DO NOT PROTECT.

AND GET THIS, THUMBTACK SAYS THAT WE PROS REQUESTED FOR THE PLATFORM TO BE LIKE THIS. LOOK AT THE CHANGES THEY ARE DOING WITHOUT PROPER NOTICE TO US PROS.

PORCH.COM IS WAY BETTER AT LEASE YOU SEE WHAT YOU WILL BE CHARGED. TELL YOUR CLIENTS TO USE PORCH

Date of experience: May 5, 2018

Thumbnail of user mjn14
Utah
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 7th, 2020

I should have known. I read through the reviews before signing up, but we were urged by a "mentor" at the time to do it anyway. Thumbtack will charge you A LOT for horrible leads. You will pay dearly for people who are tire-kickers, extreme low-ballers, have ridiculously high expectations, and even for those who admit they changed their mind on the project at all. (Yes, I have written proof). It doesn't even matter if you set your calendar to "unavailable", they will still charge you for leads that come through, but here's the kicker -- you will only get "Thumbtack credit" for the theft. Apparently, it is against their policy to actually refund money that they take from you for any reason. It just hangs out within Thumbtack forever. (Yes, I have proof of this too). Oh, and here's another huge red flag (as if you need any more, right?). Leads started to dwindle down to maybe one lead per week. Within 30 minutes of setting my calendar to unavailable, I literally got bombarded with leads. HUGE red flag for me!
Do yourself a favor and find another way. ANY other way. Thumbtack will only lead you to financial ruin.

Tip for consumers:
If you are on Thumbtack as a customer looking for a Pro, PLEASE be aware that we all pay just to have a slim chance to be considered for your job. We pay regardless of getting hired, interest, or even being qualified for it. IF, for some stupid reason, you still want to look for Pros' through Thumbtack, PLEASE make sure you are serious about hiring someone there. We ALL have to pay regardless of your decision to hire. They make a killing off of us Pros just because of people's curiosity.

Service
Value
Returns
Quality

Date of experience: December 7, 2020

Thumbnail of user jamesp243
Virginia
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 9th, 2016

Shane Neal Replaced the carpeting on my mfg. Home front entry landing and stairs.
The quality of his work was excellent and I would recommend him to anyone.

Date of experience: July 8, 2016

Thumbnail of user dereks41
Massachusetts
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 5th, 2016

I had my kitchen and bathroom completely remodeled. They came in, protected my furniture and appliances. From start to finish, very professional. Would definitely use there devices again.

Date of experience: May 5, 2016

Thumbnail of user brianh736
Maryland
1 review
6 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 8th, 2019

THUMBTACK use to be a perfect tool for my business but they have changed recently. I use to receive 4 to 8 quote requests a day from potential customers and now I don't receive any. The only job notifications I get now are from out of state. I work the Baltimore area and I only see requests from Pa, Va, De, NJ and DC now. This is because I removed my profile specifics in which allowed THUMBTACK to automatically charge me for quotes even if I did not respond to the quote request. In short, because I opted out of the auto charge plan, they are penalizing me by showing jobs only from other states.

Date of experience: August 8, 2019

Thumbnail of user waynek73
New Jersey
8 reviews
14 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 8th, 2018

They changed their business model
Used to be you only paid when you were hired now I have to pay as much is $20 if a customer calls me even if I dont get hired
Even Newspaper ads are a better deal than that

Date of experience: June 8, 2018

Thumbnail of user paulaw412
Florida
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 2nd, 2021

I hired a Wright Lawn Care a couple months ago. The service on the first day was ok, or so I thought. Additional work and follow-up was required to complete the work that was already paid for. Since the initial service Ive attempted multiple times to reach Lamont the owner and on every occasion he promised to come back to complete the services that was paid for. Lamont is quick to take a new account and take your money but be sure to triple check everything he did for you before you PAY HIM. If you have follow-up care that's needed based on the incomplete work he performed, you will never ever see him again once he has your money.

BE WARY OF HIS WORK. TERRIBLY DISSATISFIED AND HAD TO HIRE SOMEONE ELSE TO REPAIR WHAT HE WAS PD. TO DO BUT NEVER COMPLETED!

Service
Value
Quality

Date of experience: July 2, 2021

Thumbnail of user thumbtackt
Thumbtack-Support -. – Thumbtack Rep

We're so sorry to hear that your experience hiring a pro through Thumbtack wasn't up to par, Paula. We have high expectations of services on our platform and when something goes wrong, we expect pros to work to resolve those concerns. Our Trust and Safety team is trained to help in these situations and you can always report this to our team at https://help.thumbtack.com/report-a-concern. A member of our team can then reach out to you to find out more and help you work towards a resolution. You can also contact our team via one of our social media channels and we can get your information passed along. We hope to hear from you soon so we can work to better your experience in the future.

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Thumbtack is a technology leader building the modern home management platform. Through the Thumbtack app, people can effortlessly care for their homes — confidently knowing what to do, when to do it, and who to hire. Bringing the $500 billion home services industry online, Thumbtack empowers millions of people to fix, maintain, and improve their most valuable asset. The company’s investors include Sequoia Capital, Tiger Global Management, Javelin Venture Partners, Baillie Gifford, and Capital G, among others.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user thumbtackt
Thumbtack-Support -.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Thumbtack?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Thumbtack?