• J.Jill

J.Jill

Write a Review

Overview

J.Jill has a rating of 1.7 stars from 139 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about J.Jill most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and long time problems. J.Jill ranks 2126th among Women's Clothing sites.

  • Service
    43
  • Value
    43
  • Shipping
    41
  • Returns
    40
  • Quality
    44

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 16.7%
Positive
1
Neutral
0
Negative
5
See all photos
How would you rate J.Jill?
Top Positive Review

“Medium is the new large...”

Annette J.
2/26/24

Sizes in knit tops have become totally unreliable. This season Medium has become the new Large...JJill has been my source for these tops for years...every thing from shoulder-to- Hip length, sleeves, neckline is now larger and looser The rounded hems are long and clingy. So disappointing. I give up.

Top Critical Review

“Need Lessons in Customer Service”

Shirley K.
8/2/24

Third time in past six months with online ordering. When I call to correct their issues, get bad attitude. Rudeness and lack of accountability. Excuses for J Jill lack of professionalism and honesty. Consistently overcharge, will not honor their sales promotions., will not refund promptly, the lists of their incompetence is too long for this review.

Reviews (139)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (33)
Thumbnail of user shirleyk401
Ohio
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 2nd, 2024

Third time in past six months with online ordering. When I call to correct their issues, get bad attitude. Rudeness and lack of accountability. Excuses for J Jill lack of professionalism and honesty. Consistently overcharge, will not honor their sales promotions., will not refund promptly, the lists of their incompetence is too long for this review.

Products used:
Have not yet received this order due to J Jill incompetence

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user eileenm876
North Carolina
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
April 26th, 2024

Went to return an online item. #1 saleswoman told me she was involved with a sale, sent me to #2 saleswoman. #1 continued to talk with me (loudly) suggesting that I shop the sale while #2 worked on my return. #1 never shut up. She was waiting on 2 middle aged sisters and mom. While they paid, they continued shopping and trying on clothes. Very chaotic! #1 continued talking loudly, even when they wern't paying attention. Meanwhile #2 asked for my telephone number 4x's and put my card through 3x's. #1 had to come over and help. Should have stayed to help, but her customers were spending. My return took 15 minutes and I left right after. #2 finally addressed me and apologized when she heard my irritation. Couldn't wait to get out.
Mayfair shopping center 11:30am 4/26 Friday Wilmington NC

Thumbnail of user bennettcathy38
Wisconsin
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
March 21st, 2024

I have loved Jjill for years. While the styles were awful during the Talbot years, they recovered and had very appealing styles and good fit. In the past 2-3 years they have completely gone back to big, frumpy and unstylish. I haven't bought anything there in more than an year and likely won't. I'm all for size-inclusive, but styles that work on plus sizes don't work on petites. Their whole store is frumpy, sloppy and gross. Even the XS petites are too big.

Products used:
shirts, skirts, dresses

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user aajreads
Texas
1 review
2 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 26th, 2024

Sizes in knit tops have become totally unreliable. This season Medium has become the new Large...JJill has been my source for these tops for years...every thing from shoulder-to-
Hip length, sleeves, neckline is now larger and looser The rounded hems
are long and clingy. So disappointing. I give up.

Products used:
None...returned all.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rhondap462
Arizona
1 review
8 helpful votes
  • Send Message
February 10th, 2021

I have shopped many times at Dana park, Mesa az j Jill. I have never once had an employee ever even say hi or offer to help me. Today I waited in line to pay and there was only one customer ahead of me but the employee took forever talking to the customer. I almost put the item down and left. There was another employee there but she was more interested in straightening the racks. This is the normal way I am treated every time. I like there clothes so I keep torturing myself by going back. It would be nice if they even said thank you. It is always the same attitude in there store. Do you realize the customers pay your bills!

Tip for consumers:
More clothes in xlarge. If it’s on sale it’s always a small

Products used:
Clothes

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user cc703
North Carolina
1 review
16 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 24th, 2021

For years, I have loved J. Jill's clothes. They had beautiful colors, lively linens and great quality. What has happened to J. Jill recent that they only have drab and uncomplimentary colors. I am not sure who could wear these cloths and look great. The stores are displaying these horrible colors and the stores looks depressing. There was so few "summer colors" in this year's collections I have only purchased a white tee shirt. Please go back to the days of lovely and bright linen colors and well made T-shirts.

Quality
Thumbnail of user aardvark2005
New York
1 review
5 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 30th, 2023

I have been a loyal J Jill customer for over 25 years. A couple of months ago, I was unable to pay my bill over the phone - which I is how I always pay it - because the message I received said my account had been closed by the bank. I immediately emailed customer service but was given the exact same phone number. I emailed again to let the company know I wasn't able to pay my bill using the phone number provided. I received an email response that a customer service representative would contact me. That never happened. I mailed in my payment with an explanation of what happened.
I recently received a new bill with late payment fees. Apparently no one read my note or my emails. It's a mystery to me to why the phone number I've always used to pay my bill still informs me my account was closed. So I'm done with J Jill. They had more than enough opportunities to rectify the problem but failed.

Thumbnail of user betsym42
Iowa
2 reviews
10 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 4th, 2019

PLEASE change the clothes more often. If your inventory is going to hang around for months on end, this credit card
Doesn't make much sense. I don't use it because the clothes never change! Once you visit, why go back?

Thumbnail of user katiek136
Idaho
1 review
21 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 18th, 2019

I have always loved JJill for years for their cool clothes that had a fresh fun style. Definitely a young but classy boho vibe. My three favorite blouses were silk- one pale green with Johnny Was style floral embroidery, one beautiful white on white Mexican tunic and a a textured cream tunic where the fabric was made of flowered cloth. They were expensive but so cool.
And now there is a generic looking very frumpy line. Even their timeless linen Sumer pants and camp shirts (a staple for me) are gone.
I have held onto 2 gift cards ( birthday) for two years and can't find one thing to invest in.
Please, JJill, turn it back around.

Thumbnail of user kathleenm2708
New York
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
September 28th, 2023

JJill pants used to fit me like a glove. For years. Through weight losses and weight gains, I could always find great pants that would fit. New designer and/ or manufacturer has changed the quality and style of these clothes. The staff is disinterested. Maybe overworked. I am not going to shop there again.

Products used:
One pair of pants after trying on 20. Inconsistent sizing and horrible u flattering cuts

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user dougo36
Massachusetts
1 review
9 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 5th, 2019

Rude staff, my Mother is still talking about How rude the sales woman was.It would be very difficult for her to go back to the store after such a negative experience. Saturday morning at 1030 on 1/05/2019

Thumbnail of user bridgetth5
Bridgett H. – J.Jill Rep

Hello Doug. We regret to hear your mother had an unpleasant experience shopping in one of our store locations and appreciate you taking the time to contact us. Please email us at customerservice@jjill.com, with the store location and what occurred. We would like to address this with the store directly, to improve future service for all of our customers.

Thumbnail of user batyar
New York
3 reviews
7 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 13th, 2022

I would not recommend purchasing online from this store. An order arrived three weeks later than expected and after two phone calls to the office. It seems the clothes run large, i returned a down puffer vest for exchange and regret doing so. It has been over month and no sign of the replacement nor confirmation email of the exchange. The customer rep behaved as if it were my fault for the delay, maybe he was having a hard day, either way this was not a pleasant experience. Will not be shopping here again.

Tip for consumers:
do not purchase online.

Products used:
pants. returned for exchange puffer jacket size to big......never received placement

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user marleneh41
Michigan
1 review
3 helpful votes
  • Send Message
December 6th, 2018

Worked for a good manager. The staff was very influenced by one of the Meanest Woman I ever met, certain employees do whatever they want! Rules are all over the board. I was told in the beginning by a seasoned staff member to offer "sale prices" to everyone. Do not lose a sale. When you have an immature " woman" who chose to continue to harass me no matter how much I tried to explain the " horrific situation". I am sure they won't post this, due to the Truth never wants to be exposed. It will affect the business eventually.

Thumbnail of user barbaraberkowitzs
Florida
1 review
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
April 30th, 2022

Now that I'm retired, I pick and choose my purchases according to budget.
Let it be said I still have a walk-in closet only full of current J. Jill clothing. No, I do not have a relative or friend sneaking me a "heads up" on sales or discounts.
Though let it be said:
My previous working life, the price of J. Jill clothing was secondary to maintaining and continuing to be an example of proper business casual attire. It was absolutely imperative, in my position, to look well put together. Because of my petite size and particular body habitus (under 5' and 10+ lbs over the average model size) J. Jill brand was consistently my "Go To".

I AM a verified buyer for over 20 years as my account with J. Jill can substantiate.

Tip for consumers:
Prior to shopping with J.Jill for the first time, honestly think of your sizing.
J.Jill will make recommendations on each piece of clothing you choose according to the information YOU provide. Read the detail portion of your selection to see that it fits your particular needs. Materials used are listed as well as care of garment and country of origin.

Returns are a generous 90 days. Excepts are few with CLEARLY marked “Final Sale”.

Products used:
The products I have used are all of J.Jill except footwear

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user jeanl428
Tennessee
1 review
6 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 29th, 2021

Yesterday at Friday, May 28,8:30 pm I placed an order. At 9:39 pm, May 28, I received an order confirmation and was advised I would receive an shipping. Confirmation "soon". Have not received one yet.

I called today May 29 at 6:30 pm to cancel the order (less than 24 hours since I placed the original order).
Apparently it is impossible to stop shipment since it has left New Hampshire. Where it will go from there I have no idea.
Only know deliver date is June 8th. Customer service mgr said "Oh, sometimes they ship earlier…"
-This is very deceptive. I only wish I had read reviews before ordering. My mistake!
-Only 2.5 stars out of 5.
-Out of 74 reviews 22% were poor and a whopping 49% were just flat out bad. NEVER AGAIN.

Thumbnail of user dw812
Colorado
1 review
10 helpful votes
  • Send Message
January 15th, 2018

I tried to order a pair of shoes online and struggled with their system. Today, I called and spoke to a extremely rude customer service individual to ask why my order was an issue only to find out that they don't give discounts on name brand shoes. I've ordered many, many things over the years from J. Jill and have recently notice that the items I receive are no longer of good quality. J. Jill doesn't reward long time loyal customers with discounts. I will no longer do business with them. Their styles are the same and lack originality. Poor customer service! I'll take my business elsewhere thank you.

Thumbnail of user bridgetth5
Bridgett H. – J.Jill Rep

Hello- We have sent you a private message regarding this.

Thumbnail of user marya969
Tennessee
1 review
25 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 31st, 2019

I have really tried to like the clothes, but every time I buy something, it either looks terrible after washing, or the sizing is off. I have tried on a size small in the store, which was a little small, then ordered a medium online, which was huge. I have returned so many things because of these issues. They are also poorly made ( I sew so I know what it should look like). Their prices are ridiculously high for the quality. I also bought 2 different ponchos online this week, but returned them both because I could barely get them over my head.
Very disappointed!

Thumbnail of user bridgetth5
Bridgett H. – J.Jill Rep

Hello Mary. We are concerned to hear that you were unhappy with the quality of your recent purchases and sincerely apologize for any disappointment. Please use the prepaid return label to send back any items you are not happy with, at no charge to you.

We would like to review the items you feel are not up to our normal quality standards, so we may address your concerns, but would need some personal information to research your transactions. If you are willing to share your information, please email us your full name and billing address, at customerservice@jjill.com.-Jill

Thumbnail of user melaniek124
Texas
3 reviews
10 helpful votes
  • Send Message
August 24th, 2020

I love J. Jill clothes, I have had a very good experience shopping in their brick & mortar shops, but returning purchases online is ridiculous! They wait at least 3 weeks to get and apply your return, then you have to wait until the next billing cycle to get the return. If you don't want a credit, which I don't, I want my money returned, then you're waiting probably upwards of 7 weeks. I won't be ordering online from them any more. (And by the way, I found "Carolyn" the service rep to be condescending.)

Thumbnail of user lorrainew116
North Carolina
1 review
7 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 1st, 2020

I used to be able to buy career clothes from J Jill which would keep looking good all day. Not any longer. Poor quality clothes don't look good for a professional office. Styles are being made for younger shoppers and this is not Whois buying J Jill. Please wake up and get a different designer!

Thumbnail of user terric197
Michigan
1 review
16 helpful votes
  • Send Message
May 17th, 2020

I have been buying J. Jill clothes for 20 plus years. I still have some of those first purchases. The quality has gone downhill in a big way. The sizing is also quite inconsistent now. Please bring back the quality!

Thumbnail of user maryleef5
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
July 13th, 2023

I've used this company for many years. The clothing is stylish and comfortable. Somtimes beautiful feminine details (like embroidery) help to lift an otherwise ordinary top into a different sphere. Colors tend to be soft and lovely. Customer care excellent. Highly recommend.

Tip for consumers:
Great company!

Products used:
Tops, pants, dresses

Thumbnail of user elizabethm722
Georgia
2 reviews
57 helpful votes
  • Send Message
June 25th, 2019

I have been a customer of Jjill since the early 90's. They use to have very few patterns and very good quality material. It reminded me of Eileen Fisher. Now it reminds me of an older women's store like Anthony's and now a days Talbots. I believe Jjill is owned by same company. Anyway, I wish they would learn by the clothes that get left behind each season and stop making those hideous pattens. No one under 70 should wear red, black, and white patterned anything.

Thumbnail of user lidiad1
Massachusetts
1 review
34 helpful votes
  • Send Message
October 23rd, 2017

Very disappointed to see that all customer reviews of JJill clothing have disappeared from their site, overnight, it seems. Those used to be deal makers or deal breakers for me when deciding on an item, especially when it came to sizing. This decision by JJill to remove them makes one suspicious of their real motives.
As their customer of 20 years I continue to consider them quite unique, but I have to agree with other customers who complain about their brand slowly eroding. I also used to be very fond of their jackets - anything from linen to silk, to tweed - but now they hardly ever offer any of those.

Thumbnail of user annettel350
Minnesota
1 review
0 helpful votes
  • Send Message
November 5th, 2023

I have shopped here for 20 years. My secret for great looks and fit it go into the store and try on the item. That is the only way you will know if it fits and looks great on you. I walk through the store, sit in the outfit, bend over and check all the fabric details. I certainly can't tell any of this by looking at a picture. There is a reason why pictures are labeled "fashion porn".

If you go in and on the clothes you will have a great outfit that suits you to a "T:

Products used:
sweaters, tops, tanks and jeans

Service
Value
Quality
Thumbnail of user lucym187
North Carolina
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
  • Send Message
April 27th, 2020

I've been shopping at J Jill for many years and have always been satisfied with the clothes and the service. They also have great sales, if you can wait for them. I've never had any problems with this store.

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

J.Jill offers unique and fashionable women's apparel, accessories, and footwear. Clothing available in misses, petite, tall, and plus sizes. Shop JJill? ۪s inspired style collection.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user bridgetth5
Bridgett H.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about J.Jill?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about J.Jill?